4 ms·
More proof that it is unlawful to continue holding her, as the Grumbles motion her team submitted last month stated. Further imprisonment will not cause her to
by boomboomsubban 7y ago
More proof that it is unlawful to continue holding her, as the Grumbles motion her team submitted last month stated. Further imprisonment will not cause her to talk, so it is unlawful to imprison her.
Hope she recovers quickly.
- warent 7y agoIn my opinion, she should be free. That being said, I don't think an emotional outburst is "more proof" (maybe you meant more evidence) that it is unlawful to hold her. Can you imagine going in from of a judge and saying "my client attempted suicide in prison, that means it's unlawful to hold her." The precedent would allow basically any prisoner who attempts suicide to be released.
- somesortofsystm 7y agoWell, one wouldn't just go 'in front of a "judge"' in this case, but rather also present a long and sordid history of Chelsea's very real torture by her captors. Chelsea has been kept in inhumane conditions which completely violate her human rights, for years. She has been very seriously tortured - physically, psychologically - by any measure. Chelsea has had no justice. She is not a criminal, but rather a victim of a criminally corrupt military-industrial-pharmaceutical complex hell-bent on having its crimes covered up, by any and all means possible. "National Secrecy" has meant, for too long, 'our citizens will burn us to ashes if they find out what we have done'. Secrecy corrupts. The empire will come unraveled with every secret kept, revealed. The degree to which extremely corruptive measures (indefinite detention, 'black sites', secret courts) are taken, is indicative of just how much criminal behavior is being 'protected' by the Defense Department's lawyers ..
- philwelch 7y agoFor instance, Jeffrey Epstein.
- kleer001 7y agoYeah... whatever happened to him? I hope his story gets back into the news cycle after this Pandemic blows over.
- deadmetheny 7y agoHe's still dead, last I heard.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoHe was killed. The story left the news cycle before coronavirus happened. So many rich and powerful people were close with him... I don’t think the story is coming back unless unavoidable new evidence is released.
- jascii 7y agoHow is this relevant to the current discussion?
- philwelch 7y agoThe post I was replying to argued: > Can you imagine going in from of a judge and saying "my client attempted suicide in prison, that means it's unlawful to hold her." The precedent would allow basically any prisoner who attempts suicide to be released. In order to support that point, I provided a concrete example. Jeffrey Epstein attempted to commit suicide in prison, but Jeffrey Epstein was also the exact type of person who shouldn't be freed from incarceration.
- droithomme 7y agoI disagree with your framing of suicide as an emotional outburst.
- zouhair 7y agoSuicide is the epitome of emotional outburst.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoThe point of this kind of custody is to persuade someone to comply with the court. That the person in question would literally rather die means it isn't going to work.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoIt is more proof that she is not being coerced into testifying by this imprisonment, meaning it is unlawful to continue imprisonment. Most prisoner are in prison to pay their debt to society, Manning is in to coerce her to testify.
- jsjddbbwj 7y agoThe fact that a criminal has tried to kill himself in prison is proof that he shouldn't be there...?
- leggomylibro 7y agoPlease don't misgender people; it's rude, like intentionally calling someone by the wrong name. And Chelsea is not serving a sentence for committing a crime; like the article states, she is being detained indefinitely for refusing to testify.
- sevenf0ur 7y agocontempt of court is a crime
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- leggomylibro 7y agoAnd has a jury convicted her of that crime? No.
- Karunamon 7y agoI think contempt is unique in that it is summarily imposed by a judge for failing to follow a lawful order, correct?
- leggomylibro 7y agoI would believe that there are legal precedents for unilaterally detaining someone for an indefinite period of time. But I also believe that it is a clear violation of the 6th and 8th amendments to indefinitely detain someone without a trial. These sorts of extreme and unusual actions erode the credibility of the entire judicial system in the eyes of the public.
- smsm42 7y agoHow does it prove that it's unlawful? As far as I know, the law does say that if you refuse judicial order, you will be imprisoned. If you really really really don't want to comply with a judicial order - there's no exception in the law that says "well, if you really don't want to - then it's ok, you can violate any judicial order, but only if you feel really strongly about it". The law is not about anyone's feelings. However you feel about what Manning thinks or does, it does not change the law, and by law it's certainly lawful to hold Manning until the compliance with the judicial order is achieved. That's the only way these orders can work - otherwise anybody who gets unfavorable order will just refuse them and say "no matter what you do, I will never comply so you can as well give up now".
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>if you refuse judicial order, you will be imprisoned. You will be imprisoned to coerce you to comply with the order. If you are uncoerciable, it is unlawful to imprison you for refusing the order. Anybody can get out of an order like this, just most people can be coerced.
- smsm42 7y ago> If you are uncoerciable What does it mean "uncoerciable"? There's nothing particularly "uncoerciable" in Manning - we don't know the future and Manning is as human as anybody else. If this law applies to all other humans, it applies to Manning too.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoImprisonment clearly isn't enough to coerce her into complying. There may be other methods that could coerce her into it, but they would be obvious violations of the eighth Amendment.
- smsm42 7y ago> Imprisonment clearly isn't enough to coerce her into complying By your logic, we should not imprison recidivist criminals, as prison is clearly not enough to deter them from further crimes. So we should just give up, shrug and release them, because apparently nothing can be done about it. In fact, if the criminal solemnly swears they'd go back to the life of crime as soon as they are released from prison, we should immediately release them as it is clear that keeping them in prison would not coerce them to comply with the law, and thus is completely pointless.