3 ms·
Salaries are in large part determined by local factors: cost of rent, food, gas/public transport, tax rates, etc. There is no "universal" salary for a particula
by keiferski 7y ago
Salaries are in large part determined by local factors: cost of rent, food, gas/public transport, tax rates, etc. There is no "universal" salary for a particular position. Developers in San Francisco are not paid 3x of those in Des Moines because their skills are 3x better. Their salaries are higher because living in SF is more expensive. If the cost of living in SF were lower, the salaries would be lower, too.
If anything, pushing for a worldwide universal salary would likely lower earnings of the top X%, simply because most of the world isn't as expensive as SF/NYC/London.
- eloisant 7y agoSoftware companies like Gitlab don't address a local market. They target a global market, which is the same no matter where you're based and no matter where your employees live. If you can afford to pay San Francisco developers a given salary, you can afford to pay Des Moines employees as much. Let the employees benefit from their cheaper location rather than taking that away from them. Otherwise where is the incentive to declutter cities?
- FartyMcFarter 7y agoThe incentive to declutter cities is not Gitlab's.
- keiferski 7y agoI am making a more fundamental point, which is that the current developer salaries (in general, worldwide) would not be as high if the cost of living were not high in the specific places where software companies congregate. These high salaries would otherwise not exist, because they are not based on an objective skills or supply-based metric. It is not as if SF developers are 3x more skilled than Des Moines ones. Clearly the assumption that salaries should factor in the cost of living is a factor. In a lot of ways, this extremely high baseline benefits everyone else in the industry, even if they don't directly work in SF/NYC/etc. The salaries of Des Moines developers are probably higher than they would otherwise be, as compared to other professions. And while it's nice to think that companies should pay people the maximum amount of money that they can afford, this is unfortunately not a rational economic move and it will collapse the moment any financial difficulties come into play.
- DrScientist 7y ago> because they are not based on an objective skills or supply-based metric Then you have to ask why do these clusters exist - with high skills, high salaries and high costs? In my view, that's because there is value created by proximity. It is more productive to have people co-located in the same office. Also if you live in a major university town, or high tech area then that accelerates the exchange of ideas, particularly outside peoples direct areas of interest. This makes for better networked, more creative employees. Co-location of companies also increases the chances of collaborations and deals.
- bluGill 7y agoThe context here is an all-remote company though. As such they have rejected the advantages of proximity. They should be searching out the great but cheap people who want to live elsewhere.
- ghaff 7y agoTBH, if I were running an all-remote company, I'm not sure how hard I would try in general to match comp with big Silicon Valley employers. It's actually not clear to me that GitLab really does either. The pay scales for other popular cities are only about 10-20% below SF. The phenomenon where of Googles/Facebooks/etc. offering mostly very attractive comp in spite of Bay Area CoL is actually relatively recent. Going back a couple of decades I looked at some employment options in Silicon Valley and the comp uplift wouldn't have covered the higher CoL relative to Massachusetts. And the companies freely acknowledged this.
- DrScientist 7y agoBut if those great people have any sense they will be working for a company that recognizes and rewards their skills and not simply offers a rate based on the area of the world they are in. ie great people don't want to be competing on cost for work, unless they can capture some of the value of their greatness. eg price for work completed rather than by the hour - so if they finish it in the half the time then they keep that value. On the other hand, people currently average skill or below ( half... ) are more likely to be better off being paid by the hour. So if you take a pure economic view, and everyone was behaving rationally, then a cost based hourly recruitment model gets you average and below workers. ie you get what you pay for at equilibrium. Of course what they are hoping is to exploit not being at equilibrium - countries with relatively high skills and low costs. However they are going to be competing with companies based in those lower cost countries ( eg India ), who have both the low cost environment advantage and the ability to recruit locally and better select and retain employees. My experience of working with even locally based companies that compete on price is high staff churn ( as the good ones find better employment ) - which really damages productivity.
- aidos 7y ago> If you can afford to pay San Francisco developers a given salary, you can afford to pay Des Moines employees as much. That’s not really true. There are companies with a few employees in expensive locations and many in low income regions. If you switched everyone to the same salary you’d bankrupt the company. I certain don’t assume to know what Gitlab’s financials look like. What if a company is paying above market rates for all their employees in their chosen locations? As a thought experiment, assume each of those people was the most suitable employee in their field. You’d pay them what they wanted in order to make it work. What if one of those people had a special situation with say dependants? Would you pay them a little more to relive that so they could work for you effectively?
- hawkice 7y ago> That’s not really true. There are companies with a few employees in expensive locations and many in low income regions. If you switched everyone to the same salary you’d bankrupt the company. I certain don’t assume to know what Gitlab’s financials look like. There's a slight of hand going on here, where you at first assume all employees are fungible, to mention it's not possible for some firms to pay all employees the same. But then you ignore that, before someone is hired, when they're merely a potential-hire, they _are_ (basically) fungible with all the other potential-hires. If you can afford the most expensive one, you can afford the cheaper one. No one suggested paying everyone the same huge amount. But if you are paying Huge Amount X, that can go anywhere.
- afiori 7y agoBut that is the reason why San Francisco has higher pays, there is a huge competition between employers. In practice what you propose is not to hire in expensive places.
- hawkice 7y agoI mean, I strongly encourage all people who, when presented with the option of getting a very good deal on an expensive and valuable thing, to take it. In equilibrium, you'd expect someone's programming skillset not to massively drop in value because they moved slightly far away in essentially the same legal jurisdiction. Until we reach that equilibrium, there is money waiting to be collected by firms who hire American engineers to work remotely.
- tiborsaas 7y agoWe are addressing a global market too at TransferWise and London developer salaries are way different than Budapest salaries. We are also not a remote company... until next week :)
- yakshaving_jgt 7y agoWouldn't that be a good thing though? Isn't that an important part of Capitalism? Competition?
- WJW 7y agoGood for who though? It's certainly not good for the people competing. Check out Peter Thiel wanting to be the monopolist: https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-losers-1410535536 https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-...
- jbay808 7y agoI keep hearing this explanation. If it were true shouldn't it correspond to an additive bonus, rather than a multiplicative scaling factor?
- pkolaczk 7y agoIt's reversed. Living in SF is more expensive _because_ the salaries are higher but space is scarce. Salaries are higher because of concentration of high-tech companies which make a lot of money and are not neccessarily pressed to hire cheap. If they were, they'd move these jobs to India anyways. People come attracted by good jobs, but it turns out it is hard to find a place to live with a good commute. The demand drives prices high.
- sleepychu 7y ago> Salaries are in large part determined by local factors Salaries should be a function of value produced amortized across the convenience and reliability of a predictable salary for the employee. Where I am sitting has no bearing whatsoever on the value produced and it is the primary thing that prevents me from pursing a job at gitlab. Also this argument ignores the side benefits having an enormous salary offers you. (e.g. X% into your pension is a bigger number) > If anything, pushing for a worldwide universal salary would likely lower earnings of the top X% Sounds fine to me.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> Salaries should be a function of value produced amortized across the convenience and reliability of a predictable salary for the employee Salaries should be the equilibrium price where an employers willingness to offer a salary meets an employees willingness to accept one. The only surprising thing about their scale is that they’re willing to hire people in high cost-of-living locations at all.
- sweeneyrod 7y agoIf you're refusing to pursue a job at Gitlab because it would pay less then the market rate where you live then the issue isn't that their salaries vary geographically but just that they don't pay enough in your area. If you you object even though they pay higher than your local market rate then you have a weird aversion to money that I don't see a reason for anyone else to care about.
- sleepychu 7y agoI currently live in a major city but have plans to move to a lower cost rural area. If I did that while I was working at Gitlab they would slash my salary and reap my cost saving, do you think I would be generating less value for them in exchange?
- sweeneyrod 7y agoThere are two answers to this. One is "No, but prices aren't determined by 'value'. Having air to breathe is very valuable, but it's free! You've got to consider supply as well as demand." The other is "Yes. Previously you were the most efficient source of code per dollar they could get (on the margin). Now you aren't."