3 ms·
Exactly, Magic leap has an ambitious software ecosystem vision that they have had trouble to realize - neither content producers, nor end users showed up in mea
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
Exactly, Magic leap has an ambitious software ecosystem vision that they have had trouble to realize - neither content producers, nor end users showed up in meaningful quantities so far. You can't sell what you don't have. At best it's going to take lots more in investment to make this work, if it ever will. Doubts about that are what is probably driving these rumors.
They are also a hardware company with some cool patented solutions that seem to more or less work. IMHO any of the big companies could be potentially interested in adding that core technology to their portfolio. That's worth something but maybe not ten billion.
What they don't have is the operational side sorted to build and ship products in volume (at least not as far as I know). They are shipping a product in limited volume to developers only and so far the reception of this device has been luke warm. Presumably this is not the final version.
The reason they are allegedly looking to sell is either that they are running out of funding and are having issues securing more and/or because it's clear that their current strategy is failing.
The real question of course is what investors stand to lose their money and what kind of financial constructions they can come up with in terms of equity swaps, and portfolio consolidation to protect their investment and turn this into an acquihire/IP grab. I hear Google has a lot of money in this already and its CEO is on the board and it has a history of doing AR stuff (and not quite succeeding). Jack Ma is on the board too.
- onion2k 7y agoGoogle has a lot of money in this already... My comment wasn't really about Magic Leap, but just valuing companies in general, but to address this particular point the fact Magic Leap is looking for a sale could be seen as Google's reluctance to invest more money, or even that Google is looking for a way out. Neither is particularly good for Magic Leap. The fact someone invested in a company in the past doesn't mean they still believe the company has value or is worthwhile investing in now. The sunk cost fallacy applies here.
- baybal2 7y agoThe point may be Apple being very close to releasing their own version. They had close relationship to them, and they may know something others don't. Even their initial stratospheric valuation came almost solely from them being a potential competitor to Apple's product, or an ip blocker, and an expectation that Apple will spare no money to buy them. In Shenzhen, rumours were flying for quite some time down to photos of "suspicious HDI PCBs" with "property of Apple corporation" on them. And the fact that Foxconn has only one HDI PCB contractor in the city, gives a lot of credibility to that.
- onion2k 7y agoEven their initial stratospheric valuation came almost solely from them being a potential competitor to Apple's product, or an ip blocker, and an expectation that Apple will spare no money to buy them. There are a couple problems with this theory. Firstly, it's pure speculation that Apple are even trying to make an AR headset. They might not be. Secondly, if Apple are and they've managed to get as far as making PCBs in Shenzhen without licensing any IP from Magic Leap then Apple believe they don't need to license the IP. Apple might be infringing and ML might be able to sue, but that's speculation. If Apple has managed to make a headset without infringing then ML's IP is basically worthless because no one else will need it either if they take whatever route Apple have taken. To be honest I imagine if Apple wanted access to ML's tech they would just have invested in them during one of the many rounds ML went through, and then negotiated a favourable licence agreement between the two companies. It would have been much cheaper, they'd have access to the tech earlier, and it would have prevented someone else offering more.
- flyinglizard 7y agoYou’re wrong about their lack of ability to manufacture at scale. This part they have nailed down and used a lot of the capital to get right. It’s just that the units haven’t sold. You could argue about unit economics though.