4 ms·
You basically described PoW (proof-of-work) mining, which was (imho) the actual innovation with Bitcoin. The current idea though is to build a byzantine fault t
by latchkey 7y ago
You basically described PoW (proof-of-work) mining, which was (imho) the actual innovation with Bitcoin. The current idea though is to build a byzantine fault tolerant system that doesn't require massive amounts of "wasted" power. I put wasted in quotes because it is actually doing something, it is just the output isn't useful for much more than validating the transactions.
Interestingly, Maker is currently built on top of (Ethereum) PoW. Some day, ETH2, which is PoS (proof-of-stake), will solve all the same issues you're talking about. Or at least that is the dream. We will then have a pretty amazing digital rube goldberg machine where we can sit back and watch the gears turn.
- analognoise 7y agoI was looking at Etherium recently, and thought HBM on the new Xilinx Alveo would be perfect to attack the problem. I wish I had an Alveo board. Sheesh, now would be the time. You could fit the whole DAG into HBM.
- latchkey 7y agoTake a look at the light eval method [1]. Even with HBM on the card... while it will hash fast, you're still going through the memory controller. What you need to do is skip that. Get rid of the memory hardness entirely. Generate the DAG on demand. [1] https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/progpow-audit/blob/master/Bob%20Rao%20-%20ProgPOW%20Hardware%20Audit%20Report%20Final.pdf https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/progpow-audit/blob/m...
- snisarenko 7y agoPoS will not solve anything. PoS is just obfuscated proof of work. The same amount of "resources" will be wasted in a PoS system, its just going to be a different type of resource. Required reading http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ HN Discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16451187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16451187 Also newer article http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pos-still-pointless/ http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pos-still-pointless/
- rahimnathwani 7y agoWhy does MC=MR imply TC=TR?
- decentralised 7y agoThat's not even close to being correct, and blogs from maximalists are never a good source of correct information. Happy to walk you through what PoS looks like in 2020, but you can look up the information yourself too.
- ShorsHammer 7y agoGiven the unwillingness to back up your argument, would you instead simply show one pure Proof of Stake system that is used today?
- decentralised 7y agoIf you can define "pure" in terms of how it relates to energy consumption, I can try. The one PoS system I'm (edit: deeply) familiar with is Ethereum 2.0's, I wrote about it a couple of years back: https://medium.com/@jpa_of_snc/consensus-casper-and-cryptoeconomics-in-15-minutes-or-less-c7ca2427bf88 https://medium.com/@jpa_of_snc/consensus-casper-and-cryptoec... There are testnets using this already: https://medium.com/prysmatic-labs/ethereum-2-0-phase-0-testnet-release-1e9e682db910 https://medium.com/prysmatic-labs/ethereum-2-0-phase-0-testn...
- ppf 7y agoTell me, what does PoS look like in 2020, apart from delayed? ps. Using the word "maximalist" immediately shrinks your audience to other die-hard crypto fans.
- decentralised 7y agoI'm not in it for the audience.. in any case, maximalism is mostly a self-assigned title and the author of that blog describes himself as such edit: how can something that is being discovered be late? The work on PoS is almost completely greenfield and far from trivial. Many people made many far too optimistic comments about how long it would take to get it right but no one can say it's late...