4 ms·
> Which is the goal, reduce infection rates. There are tens of thousands of incubating cases in the United States already. How exactly is a few dozen sick pa
by ajross 7y ago
> Which is the goal, reduce infection rates.
There are tens of thousands of incubating cases in the United States already. How exactly is a few dozen sick passengers per day going to affect that at all? You'd have to literally be picking up and flying in planes full of active cases to even match what we have here already.
This is insanity. No one with any expertise at all recommended it. No one serious thinks this is a good idea. It's not going to do anything useful at all.
- briffle 7y agoIt's security theater, just like airport security screening. The politicians need to be seen doing something.
- KarlKemp 7y agoDon't put this on "The Politicians". There is exactly one politician in the world that sees closing the borders as the solution to all their problems.
- hellotomyrars 7y agoWhat? I can't even tell if this is supposed to be about Trump. Also it doesn't matter. There are thousands of borders and even more politicians on this planet and if you don't think borders are the scapegoat for problems the world over, then you're really thinking very small.
- anigbrowl 7y agoTo be fair there's quite a few of them, but I get our point.
- jvm___ 7y agoIt's also on message. America First. You stop coming here. You're the problem, I alone can protect you from the bad hombres/virus people... Don't look into yourself and see what can be fixed, always blame the other.
- triangleman 7y agoYep, notice how in the speech how many times he mentioned China and blamed Europe for not closing off to China. Unfortunately this kind of measure is going to increase the R0 of the virus, because some people will think "oh I see, the virus is over there, and now the president has closed off that vector."
- Dirlewanger 7y agoPart of that message isn't wrong. The virus didn't originate in the US.
- ajross 7y agoStatistically, it did. The overwhelming (!) majority of COVID-19 cases in the US are domestically transmitted. Who cares where patient zero came from at this point? Banning travel is going to do nothing.
- dx034 7y agoAny restriction in travel will help to slow the spread of the virus. If you look at Europe, a sizeable number of cases outside of Italy are still travel related. Stopping all travel is one of the key measures to keep infections local. I'm not saying the measure suffices. Obviously domestic travel is also a big issue, as is travel from outside the Schengen area. But being one of the people affected (currently in Schengen), I still believe this is a right step. It might not slow infections down enough but it will certainly prevent many cases. Also, it will remind people how serious the situation is.
- heedlessly3 7y agoThis will still definitely slow down the total amount of infections. >You'd have to literally be picking up and flying in planes full of active cases to even match what we have here already Even one person with corona can do a lot of damage. For example, a singular person boarded Diamond Princess. The ship had 696 confirmed positive cases and 7 deaths from 1 person who had the virus.