3 ms·
”as long as you're not hurting anyone / planning to hurt anyone” By that definition, car racing on public streets, running red lights and ignoring speed limits
by Someone 7y ago
”as long as you're not hurting anyone / planning to hurt anyone”
By that definition, car racing on public streets, running red lights and ignoring speed limits is absolutely fine, as long as you’re not hurting anyone / planning to hurt anyone.
Regulations that limit the risks people get exposed to exist for a reason: you can’t undo damage done to others by punishing the culprit. That’s why, for example, reckless driving is illegal.
Lots of things are only legal, not when companies do it, but when those doing it follow safety protocols.
- jessriedel 7y agoNo one was alleging that him keeping the explosives at home was putting anyone but himself at risk, which makes it crucially different from speeding. The idea behind these explosives laws is to catch people intending to cause harm while they are plotting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rcurry 7y agoYou’re talking apples and oranges here - public streets are filled with, well, the public, and we have laws against racing and running red lights for that very reason. On the other hand, if you own forty acres in New Mexico and want to blow up an old washing machine with a pound of C4 on a lazy Saturday afternoon, well, more power to ya.
- Someone 7y agoI’m not saying people shouldn’t be able to do that, just that, if society sets rules, they should be followed, and can restrict what you can and cannot do. For example, if you buy that C4, how does it get on your land? If you make it yourself, how do the ingredients get on your land? Is that safe for the public? Does the process produce waste (gases, liquids) that may cause damage to neighbors or the environment? If one of your experiments doesn’t go ‘boom’, do you toss what’s left in the garbage bin, or do you think that should be regulated? Do you make precautions so that playing kids can’t accidentally enter the area? Do you calculate how far parts of that washing machine may get thrown away, to make sure parts don’t end up in your neighbors house?
- tathougies 7y agoNo, I think experimenting with explosives on public streets should be illegal. But experimenting them on your private property or that of someone else who has let you do so should be legal. I also think car racing should be legal on private property.