3 ms·
At least on its surface, I'm kinda okay with this 1000-person rule for several reasons: - I've already accepted that fire codes can legitimately limit the numb
by DoofusOfDeath 7y ago
At least on its surface, I'm kinda okay with this 1000-person rule for several reasons:
- I've already accepted that fire codes can legitimately limit the number of people in a building.
- The rule is agnostic with respect to the purpose of the meeting. E.g., it's not obviously being used to suppress political or cultural movements.
- It has a real, plausible purpose for public safety.
That being said, I can also see some valid reasons against it:
- It sets precedent, which is a powerful factor in the U.S. court system.
- The 1000-person rule seems a bit arbitrary. I would think the number needs to be much smaller for the effect to be meaningful. And I'm guessing something more nuanced is what's really needed, for example spacing between persons, air recirculation / flow rates, frequency of surface cleaning vs. # persons present, etc.
- It implicitly discriminates what kinds of groups can meet as before. One salient example would be that Christian mega-churches and really large Roman Catholic parishes couldn't meet as before.
- It also potentially prevents mass protest marches, depending on the wording of the ordinance, and how willing protestors are to ignore the ordinance.
- ocdtrekkie 7y ago> One salient example would be that Christian mega-churches and really large Roman Catholic parishes couldn't meet as before. This is one scenario where I wouldn't be surprised if there are groups that refuse to uphold the order and file lawsuits over it infringing on their right to practice their religion (and assemble, of course).
- burlesona 7y agoIt could happen, but at least in SF it's gone the other way. The Catholic Schools were the first to close, all 90 schools are now shut down.
- ken 7y agoMega-churches broadcast their sermons on TV already. They're better prepared for this than almost any other group.
- djsumdog 7y agoReminds me that the church shooting in Texas was literally live streamed. The church I grew up with recorded mp3s of sermons at put them on their website, and that was way back in the very early 2000s.
- jpindar 7y agoCatholic churches will just add more masses. The schedules are flexible (any time from Saturday afternoon to Sunday evening counts as Sunday mass) and masses can be made much shorter than they usually are.