3 ms·
I'm hoping for a ruling that can be basically summed up as "The merger doctrine is evaluated at the time the copying takes place, therefore we reverse the feder
by gpm 7y ago
I'm hoping for a ruling that can be basically summed up as "The merger doctrine is evaluated at the time the copying takes place, therefore we reverse the federal circuit and don't have to decide the rest of this nonsense".
Explanation: The merger doctrine is the doctrine that if there is only one way to write something it isn't copyrightable/copyright infringement. Alsup (the original judge) interpreted this as being interpreted at the time Google copied the API, at which point in time there was only one way to write an API compatible with existing java programs, thereby killing Oracle's case. The federal circuit reversed based on the idea that it should be interpreted at the time of the creation of the copyrighted work, at which time there was no reason to favor calling something "java.lang.String" instead of "java.std.String" and so on.
Fair use is a lot more complicated to deal with than the merger doctrine. Ruling based on it will almost certainly result in a lot more pointless court cases as people debate whether or not this instance is fair use.