6 ms·
Do we have any good theories about mechanisms for this other than "One obvious explanation is that women at more elite colleges married richer classmate men, an
by Symmetry 16y ago
Do we have any good theories about mechanisms for this other than "One obvious explanation is that women at more elite colleges married richer classmate men, and so felt less need to earn money themselves."?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoWhich should also lower men's salaries from elite colleges. But it doesn't.
- kd0amg 16y agoDo you mean that we'd see men marrying richer classmate women and thus feeling less need to earn money themselves? I don't think our society's typical gender roles tend that way. I think sole breadwinners are usually expected to be men.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoResults were a subset among full-time workers, so no sole breadwinners.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoA common phenomenon I've observed among richer households in NY is that although both parties work, the man is still the primary breadwinner, i.e. the household finances are completely dependent on his job. (I.e., his pay might be 5-10x hers.) Typically the woman works in some job she derives utility from (often arts, fashion, teaching or nonprofits) while the man works in finance. Their lifestyle (or even 50% of it) would be completely unsustainable on her salary alone. A rich husband enables her to pursue minimally remunerative work.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoSo, could be the other way too, but isn't. The study raises the question Why?
- roel_v 16y agoOnly when men are equally likely as women to stay at home. But they aren't.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoStudy wasn't stay-at-home, was full-time workers.
- weichi 16y agoOf course there are. Which makes Hanson's next sentence - "Why don’t the study’s authors want us to hear about that?" - surprising. Overcoming Bias, indeed.
- Symmetry 16y agoYes, that the studies authors didn't find the same things salient as Hanson did is probably a better explanation than some sort of conscious hiding of results. But what would you say could be good reasons for this very (to me) puzzling data.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI believe that Hanson was remarking on the fact that, although the explanation given is plausible, the authors didn't discuss it in the paper and pooled men and women together afterwards. I don't think he was putting it forward as the only possible explanation.
- weichi 16y agoBut Hanson doesn't say "Why don't the study's authors discuss possible explanations for this finding, such as xxx?" Instead, he insinuates that the authors were perfectly aware of this possible explanation, but think that their readers should not be exposed to it for some nefarious reasons (that's what the phrase "why doesn't X want us to hear Y" means colloquially). This sentence leads me to believe that Hanson is coming to this discussion with some biases of his own. Anyway, other explanations could be that the result is not real (which Hanson does discuss at the end), or that women from these colleges choose lesser-paying careers for some reason other than that they are married to rich men ... perhaps women at elite colleges 25 years ago were unusually interested in charity work. I don't think Hanson's proposed explanation is necessarily wrong, but that phrase "why don't they want us to hear about this?" really rubs me the wrong way.
- kenjackson 16y agoObviously this is speculation on my part, but my theory is that women at elite schools are more likely to major in liberal arts fields (English, history, etc...), while those at less elite schools major in more vocational fields (nursing, engineering, etc...). You'd also need to control for major to mitigate this.
- arihelgason 16y agoIt would also be interesting to see this segmented by employment sector. Anecdotally, more women than men who graduated from my university in subjects with higher earning potential went on to lower paying careers in the art world and other creative fields.