5 ms·
Edit: Treat this as unbased hearsay, I have no way to prove it (and neither has she). In my judgement she didn't make it up. On the minister: At least he could
by atoav 7y ago
Edit: Treat this as unbased hearsay, I have no way to prove it (and neither has she). In my judgement she didn't make it up.
On the minister: At least he could get tested. I personally know a person who has the symptoms, has been to Rome and has been denied a test because they were no registered citizen in the Netherlands (Stundent from another EU nation).
Edit: maybe she fell victim to a overworked callcenter operator, who told her the wrong reason why she wouldn't get tested.
- Angostura 7y agoShe - just FYI
- cjr 7y agoshe
- toong 7y agoWhy does it even matter which country she's from ? Do you have a link ?
- atoav 7y agoA link? To what? That person told me that more or less personally and I know her for a while now (and I am not going to disclose her on here, so treat the whole thing as unbased hearsay if you like). Happened two days ago. She was given a corona virus hotline number by some university official, and after a day they called her back. When she explained her background (having been back from Rome, Student, etc) thr lady on the other end asked whether she is registered in the Netherlands, she denied and the woman said: then we will not test you and hung up without further words. Of course that is how she told the story, and she was quite angry and cynical about the whole thing, but in my judgement she didn't invent it or anything.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoSome people are bureaucratic idiots and a few are outright racists. I suggest she calls the health service hotline and explains the situation again.
- droithomme 7y agoSituations like this is how people go crazy enough they start intentionally spitting on elevator buttons and door handles. Society treats people inhumanely and some as a result decide to fulfill that prophecy and act inhumanely. When I saw the videos of Chinese people spitting out their windows and licking doorknobs I thought they were evil people. Now I realize they were driven insane by uncaring sterile hypocritical dead bureaucracy. I no longer judge them as I understand what led to their madness.
- the-dude 7y agoAlthough a lot can be said about the approach of the Dutch government regarding the Corona outbreak, this sounds hard to believe. Those responsible for deciding wether to test or not have a set of requirements, we can not test everybody.
- atoav 7y agoIt sounded baffling to me, but she is not getting tested and she is at home with the symptoms. Of course she could make the whole thing up, but I don't see any reason for her to do that I and it doesn't fit her character. Edit: I want to add, I totally understand not anybody who believes they have the virus can be tested and there has to be some measure that they have to apply. For me the most likely explaination is that the lady on the phone was telling her shit that is not part of the offical line.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wdb 7y agoI hope this student friend of yours hasn’t lived longer than four months in the Netherlands otherwise he or she is breaking the law
- icebraining 7y agoHow is that relevant?
- wdb 7y agoBecause of “ I personally know a person who has the symptoms, has been to Rome and has been denied a test because they were no registered citizen in the Netherlands (Stundent from another EU nation).” just notifying
- the-dude 7y agoThat is not much clearer. Why do you think she is breaking which law?
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThe EU has freedom of movement, but you're required to register as a resident if you stay in any country for more than three months - although if you're studying you usually have a separate student visa. In most countries residency gives you access to the local healthcare system, although to access this you usually need to register separately with a doctor/health centre.
- roel_v 7y agoShe would be violating art 2.38 of the "Wet Basisregistratie Personen", roughly "act on the central registration of natural persons" by not registering.
- droithomme 7y agoFWIW, in the past I financially subsidized all of the costs of a clinic that served undocumented migrants (aka illegal aliens). They caught and treated countless cases of Tuberculosis and even Cholera, which stopped epidemics in the community. It's complete and totally psychotic madness, counterproductive, and will lead to the fall of society, to deny basic medical care particularly for epidemiological conditions to "illegal aliens". Societies that do so rightly fall. I'm totally willing to accept and concede this woman is an "illegal alien", has no right to be in the Netherlands, is a criminal, etc. Maybe she is maybe not but let's get the bullshit out of the way and say she is for the sake of argument. Should people like this be treated and tested for virulent plagues they reasonably might have or not? What are the advantages and disadvantages of doing so? The advantages of treating plague victims seem clear, let's tighten this up and you explain to me how citizens of the Netherlands benefit by denying simple and basic treatment of plague illnesses to people because of their status as an alleged criminal or not.
- wdb 7y agoMaybe she didn’t meet all the requirements of the RIVM when she called? Did she call the GGD? I didn’t get tested by the UK/NHS either when I came back from both Asia and Milan. UK is even worse in responding than the Netherlands
- atoav 7y agoShe probably didn't, yet as she phrased it the lady on the phone asked her whether she was registered and after she denied thr lady said she couldn't be tested then and hung up. Very likely that was unhappy phrasing on the side of the person in the call center — worked in one myself and this can be quite exhausting.
- cameronh90 7y agoThe UK and the Netherlands are have performed approximately the same number of tests per capita. The response seems pretty similar in both countries in that until a few weeks ago, you didn't get tested unless you had BOTH symptoms AND relevant history (travel or contact with known cases). In the UK, there is additionally a system of surveillance testing that is being used to ensure our model of infections is in line with reality. Due to the increasing size of the outbreak, the UK switched a week ago to testing all ICU patients with symptoms irrespective of history. That is again soon to be ramped up to all ICU patients and any hospital patients with symptoms. To handle the increased testing, some NHS labs are going to be running covid tests, which means the waiting time for other testing is inevitably going to increase. This is why it's important to only test as scientifically appropriate. This optimal response may differ between countries, depending on their particulars. All that said, the UK response so far seems fairly appropriate. We've tested in line or more than any other country with a similar level of outbreak. There is, however, a general acceptance here that widespread infection is now inevitable, and the reason you don't want to impose quarantines just yet is you want to do it when they're going to be most effective at smoothing the peak. Imposing quarantine controls now just means that people are going to start breaking quarantine later on when it's more widespread and compliance is most critical. The reality is, containment is just a delaying strategy now. This is inevitably going to spread widely, and the governments are just trying to time when best to deploy their limited arsenal of weapons.
- roel_v 7y agoThe Dutch criteria, at the moment, include that you have to have a fever (38 or up), or respiratory complaints, and having been to any one of the Northern Italian provinces. Rome is not one of them. Your friend being denied a test has nothing to do with whether or not she's registered. She doesn't fit the criteria for getting tested. edit I also think you should explain this to her. I understand and recognize that not all bureaucratic procedures are equally sane or understandable, but in this specific case, she's being treated as she should be ('should' as in 'what is decided is the best', not as in 'what in a few years time we will determine would have been the best'). There is no reason for her to be jaded or put off by anything health related - people have reasons to become cynical about government services, but this is not one of them. Unfortunately circumstances like this turn people off from central measures, which then undermines future global population health, much like anti-vaxxers. Consider this your opportunity to make a tiny contribution to a well-informed citizenry :)
- atoav 7y agoI told her that (reasons why not everone can be tested) as well, but the thing that baffled her was that the lady on the phone said (or implied?) the reason she cannot be tested was that she wasn't registered. I once worked in a callcenter myself and auch things can happen quickly especially if you are overworked an in brain-melt territory.
- droithomme 7y agoThey should test her. She might have it. They have the testing capacity. Your opinion on this is incorrect. If Netherlands continues with this policy they are following in the horrific missteps of the US in restricting testing. Some homebody with symptoms that don't match? Put them at the bottom of the queue for testing if there is limited testing capacity. In the meantime, grow testing capacity as fast as you can which is 100% of political issue and not a scientific or economic one, and make as many n95 masks as possible domestically. > "she's being treated as she should be" That is a completely unmerited claim and one which causes harm.
- roel_v 7y ago