4 ms·
Every report I've read shows the risk factor for young adults is extremely low, and probably no worse than the ordinary flu. Closing down the school for a whole
by chrisco255 7y ago
Every report I've read shows the risk factor for young adults is extremely low, and probably no worse than the ordinary flu. Closing down the school for a whole semester seems like an overreaction.
- allovernow 7y agoIt's about containing the spread to spare risky populations and minimize hospital overload. Also the bit about being no worse than the flu is not true for any age group.
- zamfi 7y ago> Also the bit about being no worse than the flu is not true for any age group It does appear to be true for the very young (ages 0-9), who are at relatively high risk from flu (especially <2), but at shockingly low risk at dying from COVID-19. Admittedly not the population in consideration here.
- allovernow 7y agoYou're right about that. Children are practically immune. As I understand this has to do with innate vs acquired immunity. Children are born with very strong innate immunity and as we age innate immunity decreases while acquired immunity increases, untill old age where both decline.
- zamfi 7y agoHuh, interesting hypothesis. But I wonder why flu hits very young children so hard, then? Is SARS-CoV-2 more handily defeated by the innate system than flu?
- watwut 7y agoNew born child immune system is pretty weak. But from what I gathered, coronavirus deaths are all about pneumonia and lungs. Old peoples lungs are damaged due to being used for years.
- jacquesm 7y agoYoung adults interact with people who are not young adults. Young adults that need not be ill might end up in an ICU unit that an older person with a weaker immune system could have used to their advantage. As long as there is no vaccine this is going to be a huge exercise in resource allocation.
- chrisco255 7y agoWouldn't it make sense for high risk individuals to self-quarantine and for the rest of society to carry on? There may not be a vaccine for at least another year. They've never successfully produced a vaccine for any coronavirus, whether that's SARS or the common cold.
- jacquesm 7y agoPlenty of high risk individuals are doing just that. Even young people with immune deficiencies are at risk and are making these decisions all by themselves. But just like there is herd immunity in vaccinations there is a similar effect at work by simply ensuring that fewer people have the disease in the first place. That ensures that the chances that someone with an immune systems issue or simply an older person is limited and that when they do contract the disease that there is room for care if they should require it. This is all about getting rid of a huge tsunami of people for which there would be no care. Once the situation normalizes or there is a vaccine it all changes. But right now we are simply utterly unprepared to deal with this at this scale, and fixing that will take time. Even high risk individuals need to eat, and need visitors. Quality of life, especially for people in such high risk groups is already hit hard, the least we can do is to try to make it easier for them to get the care they need should it get to that, at relatively little expense to the rest of us.
- gowld 7y agoHigh risk individuals in a Kirkland WA nursing home were self quarantined until an outsider came in and infected them.
- gbear605 7y agoHigh risk individuals are everyone over sixty, plus anyone younger who has risk factors, such an autoimmune disorder. That’s a huge portion of the population that cannot entirely self-quarantine.