7 ms·
Most of the value of an elite education is signaling: it proves the student had what it takes both to get into MIT, and to graduate. If MIT switched to an onli
by samatman 7y ago
Most of the value of an elite education is signaling: it proves the student had what it takes both to get into MIT, and to graduate.
If MIT switched to an online-only format, that would erode the value of the latter (which, remember, is social proof, not something which is notoriously rational), while open enrollment would obliterate the former.
A semester of remote teaching won't damage the brand.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Most of the value of an elite education is signaling Not in my case (Caltech). It was clear when I got an industry job that a BS from Caltech was at about the same level as an MS from other institutions. But if the institution is large enough, one can get an elite education by careful selection of the classes and professors, and doing the maximum in those classes rather than just getting by. For example, take honors calculus, not weeder calculus. Don't avoid the math heavy classes. Don't waste your time with easy-A classes. If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education.
- theLotusGambit 7y ago> If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education. Seems like an unhealthy attitude to me. I really dislike the perspective that education is at its best when the learning is most difficult. The best teachers are the ones that make things as clear and digestible as possible. Bad teachers are the ones that want to see you sweat.
- WalterBright 7y agoIt isn't about wanting to torture students. I never learned so much so fast before or since - and there was a lot to learn. I prefer teachers that expect a lot from their students. It's not fundamentally different from athletics. If you want to be a good athlete, you're going to have to work your tail off. If you want to be an incredible engineer like Kelly Johnson, that ain't going to happen if you party through school. Nor would you have any chance of working with an engineer like him. So ask yourself - do you want to design rocket engines? or cup holders? --- BTW, as for health, I came out of Caltech a far more confident person than when I entered. I knew what I could do, and was happy about it.
- theLotusGambit 7y agoIt's wrong to treat the brain like any other muscle. It's more comparable to a neural network (pardon the tautology). You feed in data (knowledge) in hope that some of it sticks and forms new connections that you can use to better tackle new and existing problems. There's no rule of the universe that states that the process of feeding data into the brain has to be challenging. Now, I'm not arguing that hard work has no merit. Clearly, working hard can increase your rate of knowledge-consumption and get you further faster. For some people, you included it seems, that works out great. For others, the ever-present "110% or bust!" attitude can have serious mental consequences. Accepting that education can happen without rigor won't harm those that intend to push themselves anyway, but it sure would benefit the constantly stressed-out students.
- WalterBright 7y ago> There's no rule of the universe that states that the process of feeding data into the brain has to be challenging. No pain, no gain. You're simply not going to become an expert in any field, mental or physical, without a lot of hard work.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoYikes, I wonder what you think of people like me that couldnt get an elite education.
- WalterBright 7y agoI don't care if someone has an elite education or not. It's about whether they can do the job or not.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoAfter what you just said, color me skeptical. I went to a state school and got an average-ish CS degree with average-ish internships and research, how far behind am I?
- mav3rick 7y agoYou're already far behind due to your insecurities or Will an internet forum really guide your life ? An MIT grad will always have more gates open than an NCSU grad. You need to do other things in your career to lessen the gap. There is no moving past this point no matter who you ask. And no the amount of hard work you do doesn't matter. Everyone of the "elite" school students work hard.
- akhilcacharya 7y ago> An MIT grad will always have more gates open than an NCSU grad. In the immortal words of Amy Klobuchar “are you calling me dumb?” > You need to do other things in your career to lessen the gap. Such as what exactly?
- mav3rick 7y agoIf you had admits from MIT and NCSU, both full rides, which one would you choose ? Let's see what cognitive dissonance you concoct now.
- hak8or 7y ago> If you don't find yourself studying 6 hours a day, you're not getting an elite education. This is absolute nonsense and a garbage mentality, akin to gate keeping.
- WalterBright 7y agoIn my experience 4 years at Caltech, the ones who didn't flunked out. Of course, there were a couple unicorns (like Hal Finney) who didn't study and aced the tests, but they are as far beyond you and I as we are from a first grader. Me, I tried studying less, and it simply did not work. I also have a friend who flunked out of Caltech. About 10 years later he asked if he could try again, and they said sure. He got straight As this time. I asked him if he was any smarter - he laughed, and said no, just that the second time he was ready to work. I'd guess that if you attended an elite institution and got a degree without studying 6 hours a day, you're either a unicorn or a victim of the institution's marketing department.
- an-allen 7y agoCategorically disagree with that. The most valuable aspect of an elite engineering education IMO is getting to participate in a culture of elite professional academics. The spirit and energy which you learn to tackle REALLY ABSURDLY HARD problems is the most important thing I learned from my Rice EE education. Being able to find folks who were putting probes on Mars and Titan and being able to work with them to help build algorithms and visualisations to show insights from the data collected from these foreign worlds... that was the most valuable thing about my elite education... Honestly, most people don't even look at the school or even recognise it when I apply for jobs... The experience and participating with really smart people tackling really hard problems remains the most valuable thing for me 15 years after the fact.
- samatman 7y agoThis is a mistake on my part which I should have seen coming. I said "value", and that conflated value to oneself with value to and as perceived by others. Which are definitely not the same thing, and I was referring to the market value of a degree from MIT. I don't happen to think half a semester of working remote is going to do much to dampen the intrinsic value of an elite education, either. It will mark the cohort as remarkable, having shared the distinctive experience of being Extremely Online together.
- sokoloff 7y agoIt’s hard to get into MIT. Once in, it’s just not that hard to graduate. It’s a grind and parts are moderately difficult, but I think the hard filter is up-front (and lossy/random). (class of 1993.)
- drc500free 7y agoYep. The 4-year graduation rate isn't great, but almost everyone gets there eventually. I know plenty of people who just kept plugging away, dropping classes in the 10th week if they were going to fail. One extreme outlier took 17 years.