4 ms·
Skip to the summary at the end for the juicy bits (although the rest was interesting reading too). In the summary is this: "What there doesn’t seem to have be
by jedberg 7y ago
Skip to the summary at the end for the juicy bits (although the rest was interesting reading too).
In the summary is this:
"What there doesn’t seem to have been, at least in what I’ve seen so far, is any kind of structure around early-stage financing. I haven’t seen any formal networks of angel investors, and nothing comparable to venture capital. Funding seems very ad hoc, dependent on the circumstance and connections. If so, then the rise of institutional early-stage funding in the mid-20th century was a real revolution."
And I think that is the crux of it. Most people back in the day had to find wealthy people they knew, but there was no "industry" around early stage financing.
Now there is, which has probably been great for funding ideas that would not have otherwise been funded, but is also a double edged sword for entrepreneurs, as the institutions get better and better at extracting as much value as possible.
- vikramkr 7y agoI don't think it's a double edged sword, if there are more financiers there's more competition, and if it's institutionalized then terms and all become more easily compared. I think you're much more likely to get a good deal when there are multiple investors than when you have to count on the goodwill of the one investor you have access to
- jedberg 7y agoIt's an oligopoly though. The investors know each other's terms, they have no reason to compete on that aspect. They compete on other aspects, like their network with access to potential acquirers and access to subject matter experts. They don't really compete on terms, other than valuation. If anything, as things become more transparent, the deal terms are becoming more homogenized.
- vikramkr 7y agoI don't think homogenized is a bad thing though, it standardizes the process, and with swings in the market (e.g. emergence and dissapearance of SoftBank) we see deals change accordingly. By all accounts terms have changed dramatically from what they used to look like in the 80s to now, and an oligopoly is not a monopoly. Founders have some semblance of market power now, and with increased transparency people know what they're getting into and are able to make sure they're getting a deal on par with what they deserve. The competition on valuation is probably the most important part now given that most other terms are standardizes and generally founder friendly (and I don't think terms are as homogeneous among all investors as you might think, there are some crazy termsheets out there...)
- jedberg 7y agoThe terms are founder friendly, but they are no longer employee friendly. All the value that used to go to employees goes to VCs now. It's a lot harder to hire good employees when they look around and see that they have a much better chance of an equity payout with RSUs from Google.
- vikramkr 7y agoAnd if that proves out to be problematic for companies (markets aren't instantly efficient, it takes time for information to be incorporated), I think we'll see terms shift to provide portfolio companies a competitive advantage in hiring
- jedberg 7y agoThat’s not how the real world works. Just like employee wages don’t magically go up when a few employers pay more, it is unlikely that things will shift in employees favor. The situation now will just be the new normal.
- vikramkr 7y agoThen in that case, the employees aren't actually providing value to be worth the favorable terms in term sheets and aren't providing a real competitive edge and so aren't worth negotiating better terms for. I don't think that's the case, and if employees provide a real competitive advantage, then companies will need to be able to attract them to survive. I don't see a world where in the long run (and I admit that could be decades - it took that long for terms to become founder friendly) employees don't get more power if they actually bring value. All it takes is a few years of wework style Fiasco's where the founder walks away with a huge payday and workers get screwed before workers start negotiating harder, and founders that can oblige would be in a better position. And frankly, if that ends up not mattering for company success, then the employees clearly aren't worth getting employee friendly terms. I don't think that's the case though.
- gxqoz 7y agoThe recent book VC: An American History by Tom Nicholas argues that the whaling industry in the early 19th century shared many characteristics with modern VC markets. The profits of whaling vessels had distributions similar to startups (most were not profitable, a few profitable, a very few delivered excess returns). Whaling captains were incentivized similar to startup founders (returns heavily tied to how much whale oil they harvested rather than a fixed salary). Many of the families that invested in whaling ventures branched out into other industries like textiles. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/42449471-vc https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/42449471-vc
- PakG1 7y agoHah, you remind me of the scene at the beginning of The Perfect Storm where the owner of the boat explains to Mark Wahlberg's character why he gets paid so little while George Clooney's character gets paid so much. Compare sailors working the ship to the grunts working the startup.
- gxqoz 7y agoEveryone on board the ship was actually paid a share of the profits. But yes, there were disproportionate rewards to those at the top, just like in a modern startup.
- TACIXAT 7y agoIs this really so different now? Every VC seems to want a warm introduction.