5 ms·
Because, between the lines, the level of top down, military like action and trampling of civil rights that is possible in China is likely not possible here with
by lazide 7y ago
Because, between the lines, the level of top down, military like action and trampling of civil rights that is possible in China is likely not possible here without sparking a civil war - making the whole situation worse.
- Fnoord 7y agoWe'll have to see how its gonna play out in Italy after their lockdown.
- inscionent 7y agoCivil War? Do you hear yourself. Take a breath.
- wpietri 7y agoI think you underestimate the number of people with weapons, a serious anti-government attitude, and some strong beliefs that most people would consider at best wacky. I don't think a civil war is likely. But when we look at past incidents like Waco, Ruby Ridge, Oklahoma City, Jade Helm [1], and Malheur, it's not absurd. A few years back I stopped at a blueberry farm just off the highway in Oregon. In under 10 minutes of conversation, a very nice grandmother was explaining how the Obama administration had made a deal so the UN could come in black helicopters and take all their guns, but that they were ready for it. I got my blueberries and got out. But you can bet that there are a whole lot of people with guns and Millenarianist notions that are sure that this time it's really the end times, and that would not take kindly to government-enforced quarantines. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jade_Helm_15_conspiracy_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jade_Helm_15_conspiracy_theori...
- xyzzyz 7y agoIn under 10 minutes of conversation, a very nice grandmother was explaining how the Obama administration had made a deal so the UN could come in black helicopters and take all their guns, but that they were ready for it. Maybe she read about the Ruby Ridge incident, to which you only allude in the same breath as Oklahoma bombing, and knew that it was a story of a government coming to a guy minding his own business, and killing his wife, his son and his dog, for basically no reason at all.
- wpietri 7y agoThat's certainly not how I'd sum it up. But I'll let people make up their own minds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruby_Ridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruby_Ridge
- xyzzyz 7y agoI hope that at least you recognize how utterly different it is from Oklahoma bombing, which was a terrorist act, pure and simple. Note, for example, that McVeigh got death penalty, and Nichols got life in prison, while Weaver was acquitted from all charges other than failure to appear for a warrant that he was not served properly, and got over 3 million dollars of compensation from the government.
- wpietri 7y agoSure. When somebody lists things as having one aspect in common, other aspects may differ.
- nostrademons 7y agoI don't think that's all that unlikely these days. I wouldn't quite give you even odds on it, but I'd take that bet for 10:1 odds, assuming I could get paid in some currency (like Bitcoin or gold) that would still have value after the U.S. breaks up.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoHow close are we to a civil war? People have stated that someone infected with Covid19 should deliberately try to infect Republicans. They later said that they were joking. Were they? Will someone take them seriously and actually try? I say this to say that, at least in some peoples' minds, we are very close to a civil war. In the US, if the military tried to quarrantine, say, Seattle, by force, what are the odds that Antifa or somebody would look at it as the Trump-run right-wing military trying to occupy Seattle against the will of the people? Would that trigger a full-out civil war? Hopefully not, but...
- Der_Einzige 7y ago"The constitution isn't a suicide pact" is the exact wording used by Lincoln to defend suspending Habeas Corpus during the Civil War. The same exact line was used to defend Kormatsu vs United States (Japanese Internment, which is still fully legal to execute in 2020 per Trump v Hawaii) If shit gets bad, the courts will rubber stamp literally anything done in the name of national security. I fully expect constitutional rights to be thrown out the window temporarily. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suicide_pact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Constitution_is_not_a_suic...
- not2b 7y agoUS courts have consistently ruled in favor of public health measures during emergencies that arguably violate civil liberties.
- Ericson2314 7y agoIt would cause disorganized resistance and economic breakdown, but not civil war, tbh.
- lihaciudaniel 7y ago>disorganized resistance and economic breakdown Even worse, imagine all the thing we have to do to get back to our baseline economy. A civil war would be very quick
- Ericson2314 7y agoWell I'm just talking a few Waco Texas, nothing too apocalyptic on the insurrectionary front. If the government learned how to stimulate the economy for real, and starting doing some all the deferred infrastructure work, I'm sure it could lift us out of the economic woes the quarantine created. It would would just take some time to figure it out, the US governments are all brawn no brains right now, but things ran decently well in WWII so we'd get there after a while. I'm not saying this is good, I'm saying if you don't like a huge state intervention, don't pat yourself on the back saying it would go miserably enough to make the government change its mind.