4 ms·
The Soviet campaign in Manchuria started before the bombings. Japan's forces on the mainland were swept away by experienced, battle-tested, and overwhelmingly
by vkou 7y ago
The Soviet campaign in Manchuria started before the bombings.
Japan's forces on the mainland were swept away by experienced, battle-tested, and overwhelmingly large armies redeployed from the Eastern front.
Japan's plan for the defense of the home islands consisted of pulling everyone they could out of Manchuria, but relying on its resources and industry to support the war effort. This obviously required the Soviet Union to uphold it's end of their non-aggression pact. Which it didn't.
With Manchuria under Soviet occupation, and the Japanese armies routed, this plan completely fell apart. The invasion convinced Japan that capitulation was the only solution more than the bombs did.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> The Soviet campaign in Manchuria started before the bombings. No. (And also no to JackFr.) The Soviet campaign in Manchuria started on August 8, after Hiroshima but before Nagasaki. The Japanese plan to use Manchuria for defense of the home islands would never have worked. The US could have put enough naval forces there to make transport of troops and material impossible.
- vkou 7y ago> No. My mistake. I must have gotten confused because of its inter-bombing timing. The argument that it played a bigger role in their capitulation than the second bomb is still a reasonable one, though. > The US could have put enough naval forces there to make transport of troops and material impossible. Japanese war planning was quite optimistic. But once Manchuria fell, it was clear to everyone that there was no hope.