2 ms·
Your logic works both ways. If you say it's hard to measure then how do you know that get the same outcomes? "Number of procedures per capita per year" is a ho
by dalke 16y ago
Your logic works both ways. If you say it's hard to measure then how do you know that get the same outcomes?
"Number of procedures per capita per year" is a horrible measure. It assumes that procedures done is a good proxy for overall health, which it isn't. Public health (clean food and water, trash pickup, promoting exercise and outside activities, cutting down on smoking, etc) is also important.
Here's a scenario. Country A and B are identical except that country A has pushed for potable water and B has not. As a result, 10% of the procedures in country B are from dysentery, cholera, and other water-borne diseases which are relatively cheap to treat (keep hydrated with a solution of salts and sugar). As a result, country B has more doctor visits per capita, and on average these costs are cheaper than in country A. Country B also has lower life-expectancy, more days sick per year, and other measurable outcomes.
By your definition, country B has the better health care system but I think most people would prefer the overall health of country A. Therefore your measurement is not so useful as an indicator of overall health outcomes.
- bzbarsky 16y ago> It assumes that procedures done is a good > proxy for overall health My whole point is that it's not a good proxy for overall health. However it _is_ a good proxy for amount of money spent on the system. Which is how you can end up spending more but not getting better overall health. Do read what I said again. You're arguing against a strawman. Which