3 ms·
> It won't be effective and is at best false sense of security. It is about as effective as quarantining kids after mumps outbreaks The whole point of slowing
by lm28469 7y ago
> It won't be effective and is at best false sense of security. It is about as effective as quarantining kids after mumps outbreaks
The whole point of slowing down (or stopping) movements is to slow down the spread enough to let hospitals handle as few sick people at once as possible. Western europeans countries have very good health systems as long as they're not overcrowded. It really isn't rocket science. If you have 2000 beds and 6000 sick people you're fucked, if you have the same amount of beds and a continuous flow of low amount of sick people spread over weeks or months it's just a bit worse than business as usual.
It's not panicking, it's taking steps to ensure the virus doesn't get more serious than it is.
- bequestry 7y agoNot op but want to comment on how similar the situation is to something ycombinator folks might have more experience with: its essentially a DDOS attack, because the time it takes to scale resources to meet demand is longer than the rate of growth of requests.
- AstralStorm 7y agoRecovery takes too long for such preventative measures to matter at all. It increases the delay but does not reduce load. The hospitals explode almost immediately with medium to hard cases. (We know thanks to Chinese data that recovery can easily be a month for harder cases. We know how fast medical systems get overwhelmed, and how much overcapacity would be necessary.)
- lm28469 7y agoWell, we'll see how it develops, it's too early to tell but it'll be easy to compare France/Italy to the US.