5 ms·
She was 5 months pregnant being threatened with termination for not complying with a performance plan she had never seen before. They were trying to get rid of
by michaelmrose 7y ago
She was 5 months pregnant being threatened with termination for not complying with a performance plan she had never seen before. They were trying to get rid of her without doing the proper legwork to establish that she failed in any measuable fashion.
Depending on her other financial situations she might be facing financial disaster including uninsured, life destroying, medical bills plus the inability to get any other position while visibly pregnant.
It's highly likely that she was pretty much obliged to take the money regardless of how she felt.
- duxup 7y agoYou talk to a lawyer in that situation... you don't take the cash.
- pmiller2 7y agoAnd the lawyer tells you something like "maybe we could win against them in court, but it will take a year. Even if they settle, we're looking at 3 months." Meanwhile, she's still uninsured, etc.
- duxup 7y agoPotentially, but then you make that call in an informed way.
- ohazi 7y ago> She was 5 months pregnant being threatened with termination > You talk to a lawyer in that situation Stop and listen to yourself. Do you honestly not see how someone in this situation might not believe that retaining a lawyer is a realistic possibility for them?
- duxup 7y agoShe's an adult and responsible for her actions.
- ohazi 7y agoLegally, sure. Morally? At this point she's standing on higher ground than you.
- jsjddbbwj 7y agoYes, she signed, took the money, then ratted the company. Very high moral ground
- duxup 7y agoI have no idea how your moral math here works. I think this idea that she is pregnant this somehow not responsible has some terrible implications.
- ohazi 7y agoI don't think we're likely to agree here, but I'll lay it out anyway. The top-level comment tried to describe the moral high ground as directly dependent on strict adherence to the letter of the contract. This is the key issue that I object to in this thread. An action being legal does not necessarily imply that the action is also moral, and vice versa. Context matters. Intent matters. Is it moral for a company to ask an outgoing employee to sign a non-disparagement agreement in exchange for severance? Maybe. Did the company misbehave when trying to fire that employee? Is the lawyer or HR person offering the contract aware of what happened? Is somebody that's part of this chain of events knowingly trying to use this exchange to sweep a scandal under the rug? Is the company trying to use the personal or financial circumstances of the employee as leverage to get her to agree to something she normally would not agree to (i.e. "pseudo-duress")? If any of these things are true, I don't think it's moral for the company to ask for this exchange. Her decision to accept or reject the terms of the contract does not change this, especially if the company tried to use their position of power to influence her decision. Now, is she acting morally in trying to break the terms of the contract? I don't think it depends on whether or not she's pregnant, but I do think it depends on whether or not the company acted morally in offering her the contract in the first place. The moral math here is super simple. It's just karma. "If you act immorally towards other people, they might feel morally justified in trying to screw you over. Maybe they're right... maybe you had it coming." Lots of people subscribe to this idea.
- qtplatypus 7y agoIn such a situation you might not be able to afford a lawyer.
- dominotw 7y ago> trying to get rid of her without doing the proper legwork to establish that she failed in any measuable fashion. i was fired before with one day notice. It came as total shock to me since i had very good preformance reviews before that. I researched this a lot and found out that employer can fire you for no reason whatsover. They don't have to establish anything.
- pergadad 7y agoSeems to depend on the state in the US whether that is possible or not... And in the rest of the developed world this obviously just isn't possible at all.
- dominotw 7y agoYea I am in one of the at will states like the person in question.
- michaelmrose 7y agoAt will isn't a sufficient description of a complex legal situation.
- dominotw 7y agook. yea if she can prove that she was fired based discrimination. >trying to get rid of her without doing the proper legwork to establish that she failed in any measuable fashion. I responded to this quoted comment sayin that employer has to establish poor performance. I was fired with any sort of "establish" and i found out that i couldn't do anything.
- txcwpalpha 7y agoIt's much different if the person being fired is pregnant (or of another protected class). The company has to go through many hoops to make sure they have valid, documented reasons to fire someone who is pregnant so as to not be misconstrued that the reason for the firing was the pregnancy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- theartfuldodger 7y agoThat's her story. She very much could be terminated for all manners of failure and error that we don't know about. It's an HR nightmare to fire a pregnant woman, most would rather just avoid that particular claim and pay a few more months of salary
- wirrbel 7y agoI think german courts would declare the contract unconscionable and she also wouldnt have been fired that easily.
- techslave 7y agoalso, obliged to keep her mouth shut