5 ms·
Why does this still have 10 pins? 2 pins would be plenty. 12v Power, Ground, and an overlaid capacitively coupled 2 way data comms running at a few hundred
by londons_explore 7y ago
Why does this still have 10 pins?
2 pins would be plenty. 12v Power, Ground, and an overlaid capacitively coupled 2 way data comms running at a few hundred khz to send and receive status messages, fan speeds, model/serial numbers, firmware/ temperatures, on/off commands, etc.
- generatorguy 7y agoto deliver 1500 watts at 12v through one pin would be 125 amps. 5 pins each with 25A I would think you’d want at least 14 gauge per pin and even then I think they would be rather warm.
- sjwright 7y agoIf you’re sending 1500 watts directly into a motherboard, something is probably wrong. Massive power draws (CPU, GPU) would always get their own direct connection, just as they do today. Apply this simple rule of thumb: watts become heat. The only major exception to this is where the power has exited the computer via USB or similar.
- jmgao 7y agoPCIe specifies that you can get 75W from the connector, which adds up quickly.
- generatorguy 7y agoI haven't assembled a PC since the pentium 200 days. I recall hard drives, floppy drives, and the motherboard had their own power connections but not the CPU or GPU of the time. Still a single pin is probably something like a #18 gauge and would only be good for 10A before it gets too warm for comfort.
- x0 7y agoI always thought that was why the big ATX connector has multiple 12V wires, multiple GND wires, etc. To push heaps of current, but using a normal gauge of wire, rather than something huge.
- cesarb 7y ago> I haven't assembled a PC since the pentium 200 days [...] had their own power connections but not the CPU or GPU of the time That hasn't been true for a long time. Nearly every motherboard for many years has a separate "ATX12V" plug dedicated exclusively to the CPU voltage regulator input. According to Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATX12V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATX12V), the first CPU which needed it was the Pentium 4 from the early 2000s. As for the GPU, the PCI Express slot can only go up to 66W in the 12V rail (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_Express#Power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_Express#Power), and that's a software-enabled special case for GPUs (the normal limit being 25W for long slots and 6W for the short x1 slots), so higher-power GPUs need one or even two separate power plugs.
- klipklop 7y agoNot all your power requirements will go directly to the motherboard though in that single connector. For example the GPU will have its own dedicated power plug(s). I would expect the motherboard to need < 500w for most systems.
- hinkley 7y agoPretty sure his point still holds at 40 amps.
- baybal2 7y ago> Why does this still have 10 pins? 2 pins would be plenty. No, modern desktop can easily use up to 30A constant load. No way to provide so much over 1mm wires at 12V
- loeg 7y ago10-gauge is rated for 30A, though that's 3.6mm.
- hinkley 7y agoAnd it looks like 2mm and rated for 15A, and 1mm for 10A. (I thought DC current used the volume of the wire and AC the surface area, so I'm a bit surprised that wire ratings don't distinguish AC and DC. Though I suppose heat dissipation is determined by the surface area so perhaps that makes sense.)
- Gibbon1 7y agoSkin effect becomes an issue for high frequencies. But is nil at low frequencies. I used an calculator and got 8416.7115um for 60hz. Which is 8.4mm. So not an issue for power wiring under 0000.
- mrb 7y agoActually the limiting factor is the amperage rating of the molex terminals ("pins") that make the physical contact. I have expertise in this area back from the days of Bitcoin GPU mining where I built custom cables that I crimped myself after buying the molex housings, molex terminals, and wire. Each individual terminal, formally called a Molex mini-fit junior terminal, is rated either 7.0A (typical for those with 2 contact springs) or 9.0A or 13.0A (for those with 4 contact springs.) As you can imagine, most cheap PSUs and wire harnesses are made of terminals with 2 contact springs, so the three 12V wires on the ATX12VO spec allow a max of 3×7.0A = 21.0A or 252 watts. As to voltage drop caused by resistance in the wire, it will be sufficiently small with 16AWG wire which will easily carry 7A over the short distances in a PC case.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kbumsik 7y ago> 2 pins would be plenty No. You are gonna burn wires.
- loeg 7y agoWell, no; that'd be a broken design that wouldn't pass UL/CE testing. You'd instead have to use much thicker wires.
- hinkley 7y agoAnd what happens when you connect thick wires to tiny connectors?
- loeg 7y agoGo back to step 1: don't design it utterly broken? I suspect the real reason to use many smaller wires instead of two big ones is cable flexibility. There is no electronic problem with two big ones, unless you repeatedly shoot yourself in the foot. Don't do that.
- kbumsik 7y agoYou need to consider both the wire thinness and the terminal.
- loeg 7y agoGo back to step 1: don't design it utterly broken?
- mackal 7y ago1 pin is called PS_ON, this shorting to ground turns it on. 1 called PWR_OK which says everything is working in some way I don't want to research. 1 +12V for stand by. 1 +12V sense for detecting voltage drop or something. And then 2 normal +12V and 3 ground. There is 1 reserved pin as well (rectangle connector so needs even pin count)
- jleahy 7y ago> +12V sense for detecting voltage drop or something This is actually the best bit, incredibly smart idea. It's a kelvin connection to ensure that you get 12V at the motherboard, regardless of power dissipation in the wire.
- thedance 7y agoWhy is it important to have absolute accuracy on the 12V pin?
- magicalhippo 7y agoNot absolute accuracy, but you can easily drop a few volts on transmission losses if the cable is poor or damaged.
- blattimwind 7y agoIf you drop a few volts on the 12 V cable of a PC you're about to start a fire.
- CamperBob2 7y agoFWIW, the sense line is for 3.3V, not 12V. The 12V bus will see less drop to begin with, and nobody really cares too much about the voltage tolerance on that one. 3.3V is much more important.
- cesarb 7y agoThe parent comment is talking about the new specification, which doesn't have 3.3V on the connector.