2 ms·
> Go take a look at how many CAs your browser trusts, and tell me with a straight face that you absolutely trust every one of those CAs to always do the right t
by tialaramex 7y ago
> Go take a look at how many CAs your browser trusts, and tell me with a straight face that you absolutely trust every one of those CAs to always do the right thing.
OK. There are 52 of them, listed here: https://ccadb-public.secure.force.com/mozilla/CAInformationReport https://ccadb-public.secure.force.com/mozilla/CAInformationR... although perhaps don't bang on Salesforce's poor server, it seems like for some reason this isn't trivial for them to do?
I do in some sense trust them to always do the right thing, but, as the saying goes "Trust but verify". As well as trusting them I also pay attention to what I see and other people see and press them to do better when they fall short.
I actually think their record has been fairly good, and is gradually improving. It could always be better, but on the whole what I see from CAs is exactly what I'd expect from humans generally, they are lazy and incompetent and so we have to design things to take that into account. I'd expect no more from any of us.
- ori_b 7y ago>As well as trusting them I also pay attention to what I see and other people see and press them to do better when they fall short. Can you give an example of how you have personally pressed them and how they responded?
- tialaramex 7y agoSure, after Let's Encrypt posted initially at the end of February about their uh, bug, I responded in part: > That is, how many certificates were really issued to multiple FQDNs (if a single FQDN the bug described has no effect) more than 8 hours after initial correct CAA checks ? Intuitively this should be almost none, but intuitions can be misleading. Jacob responded by saying that they were "working on this analysis today" although in fact the next we heard was a complete list of arguably misissued certificates a few days later in an announcement that was linked from Hacker News and which you've hopefully seen. I wrote (in that Hacker News thread) that this was one way to answer my question :D