4 ms·
I have absolutely no problem trusting a Turkish CA for a Turkish domain. I don’t want to trust it for .com. I cannot fathom why browsers can’t pull this off.
by amluto 7y ago
I have absolutely no problem trusting a Turkish CA for a Turkish domain. I don’t want to trust it for .com.
I cannot fathom why browsers can’t pull this off.
- Cpoll 7y agoIt might lead to a false sense of security. I don't think it'd be overkill to send a request to all 52 CAs (and fail if you get conflicting answers). Then the most a trusted CA could do is DoS some sites.
- tialaramex 7y agoThey can, and Mozilla (in Firefox) does: https://wiki.mozilla.org/CA/Additional_Trust_Changes https://wiki.mozilla.org/CA/Additional_Trust_Changes > The Turkish Government CA is name-constrained to a set of turkish toplevel domains - that is, .gov.tr, .k12.tr, .pol.tr, .mil.tr, .tsk.tr, .kep.tr, .bel.tr, .edu.tr and .org.tr.
- HappyDreamer 7y agoWhat if there was a country flag or something, indicating where the CA was located -- in which country / jurisdiction? Then, let's say it's in China or Turkey or Kazakhstan, etc etc, then I would know that the politicians/police there might have decided to man-in-the-middle listen to anything I type into that website. And what if there was a Freedom of Press index number (or sth like that) next to this flag? (because who can remember all flags)
- gsich 7y agoDon't expect too much. Browsers can't even display punycode to avoid being scammed.
- tialaramex 7y agoYou absolutely can build a plugin for Firefox (and Chrome? Maybe? Sounds like some APIs needed are not finished) to add this UI feature for people who want it. Experience shows that if everybody wants a UI feature from a plug-in it won't take long until the people you were plugging into implement it natively and you can choose to take that as praise or shake your fist at them for "stealing". I recommend the former. But I doubt your new "Freedom of the Press of the CA issuer of this site" UI will be very popular because it's not at all obvious what anybody can do with that information or how to even interpret it.
- gpm 7y agoWell, for one thing, if the lock on google.com starts showing a chinese flag I think everyone who notices would know to be suspicious.
- spc476 7y agoI think that would be a wonderful idea. Show the flag (along with the lock icon) of the country of the CA. That would at least give a bit more transparency to the user of the certificate other than checking the details manually.
- Normal_gaussian 7y agoA plugin is your best bet. The flag is one thing, but the nature of the index concept ensures it will be suitable for only specific audiences. That is the validity never mind the importance of such metrics is a position of opinion.
- drdaeman 7y agoBrowser vendors are moving in the exactly opposite direction, removing visibility into any technical information beyond the green padlock icon. Today, it takes a few more clicks to see the detailed certificate information (let alone the CA name), than it used to be.
- londons_explore 7y agoWhy not constrain it to ".tr"?