5 ms·
2% of humanity is absolutely, in no way, shape or form about to die. The Korean numbers are approaching 0.5% case fatality rate, and those numbers continue to f
by arcticbull 7y ago
2% of humanity is absolutely, in no way, shape or form about to die. The Korean numbers are approaching 0.5% case fatality rate, and those numbers continue to fall. It's about the same as the flu, and no, the flu isn't killing 2% of humanity either. Y'all need to settle down and get back to work.
- philwelch 7y agoI fully expect South Korea to be an outlier in this respect.
- arcticbull 7y agoThe WHO is reporting 0.6% in China excluding Wuhan so probably not.
- empath75 7y agothe number of cases seems to have an impact on the CFR. If the health care system is overwhelmed, it'll shoot way up. That's why shutting down travel and events is important. It's the difference between .5% CFR and 3.5% CFR.
- bugzz 7y agoLooking at Korea's numbers, they are reporting 7478 cases, with 53 deaths. But they are also reporting only 133 recoveries so far. So looking at Korea's death rate so far is in no way, shape, or form accurate, as more than 97% of their cases have not yet resolved by dying or recovering. It takes time to die.
- throwaway_tech 7y agoWhy use S.Korea's numbers? Haven't they lead the best response in terms of testing and don't they have universal healthcare? It seems to me fatality rates would likely be higher in countries that: 1) aren't testing so aggressively and 2) don't have universal access to care. Maybe I am wrong though and there is good reason to believe S.Korea is the best example right now to use as a statistics model to apply across the entire world.
- arcticbull 7y agoPart of the reason their numbers are so low is because they're testing, which is revealing the stacks upon stacks of asymptomatic cases or cases which lead to the sniffles. That's why we know the actual mortality rates are so much lower than the media is screaming breathlessly about. Think about it: not a single story about the myriad people who've recovered completely, right? There've been 114,000 documented cases so far and 66,000 have recovered. The number of active/unresolved cases remains well below its peak.
- altcognito 7y agoYou're wrong, but primarily because you insist on treating human life so trivially. Get to work eh? A best case scenario, one where the actual CFR is half what the evidence shows now is 0.25%. 30% of the population gets the flu in a regular year, so, for America that ends up being a flu season that kills 10 times more people than in an average year. But you're focus on people hacking and wheezing their way to death. You're ignoring upwards of 5-15% of those people who will have to be on a ventilator OR WORSE. This is NOTHING like the flu. You would do yourself a favor also to examine what it is that Italy, Wuhan and South Korea are going through to try and stop it. They certainly aren't "GOING BACK TO WORK."
- arcticbull 7y ago> You're wrong, but primarily because you insist on treating human life so trivially. No, it's because I'm not overweighting risks that are trivial for the vast, vast majority of people. Of course if you're over 80 and have 3 pre-existing comorbid conditions (as is in Italy) you should be careful. If you're under 10, nobody's died. In fact nCoV-19 doesn't really even spread between children. If you're under 40 the mortality rate is 0.2%, and that's a worse-case number including folks with co-morbid conditions. Risk exists, and we should be comfortable with it. I recommend reading Schneier's essay on our decreasing tolerance for risk [1] and how it can often lead to us doing ourselves more harm than good. You have a 1% lifetime risk of dying in a car accident. You've got a 2% lifetime risk of dying of an opioid overdose. > But you're focus on people hacking and wheezing their way to death. You're ignoring upwards of 5-15% of those people who will have to be on a ventilator OR WORSE. This is NOTHING like the flu. Yes, it is like the flu. H1N1 Influenza A has a ~10% mortality rate in the elderly, similar to nCoV-19. > You would do yourself a favor also to examine what it is that Italy, Wuhan and South Korea are going through to try and stop it. They certainly aren't "GOING BACK TO WORK." Really the economic and individual harm and impact there has a lot to do with what they're doing to try and stop the spread. The cure is worse than the disease here. They probably should go back to work, though, and in China, they already are. They should wash their hands and stay home if they're sick, and get back to work. [1] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2013/08/our_decreasing_toler.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2013/08/our_decreas...
- kingkawn 7y agoThere is no way to state with certainty what you’ve said or the opposite. It is prudent of everyone to exercise caution and avoid panic that increases the potential for harm. Being dismissive is just a destructive as being overprotective.
- arcticbull 7y agoSure there is: the data.
- lukifer 7y agoIt's a moving target, though. Viruses mutate.
- arcticbull 7y agoIf it moves, we can re-visit, but I don't see any reason this one's more likely to mutate than influenza A.
- claudeganon 7y agoThe case fatality ratio is dependent on slowing the spread of the disease such that the healthcare system isn’t overwhelmed and so that we have time to develop treatments (possibly a vaccine). The US is not only doing effectively nothing to slow the spread, but isn’t even testing at the level necessary to assess relative regional threats and take necessary mitigation/containment actions. Arriving at a result anything like South Korea entirely depends on us responding like South Korea, something for which the window of opportunity may have already closed on in the US. We’ll certainly find out in the coming weeks and months.
- ncallaway 7y ago0.5% is still well over 5x as bad as typical flu. SK is closer to 0.7%. SK also has a far lower recovery percentage (SK total cases: 7478, total recoveries: 118; 1.5% of cases have recovered, 0.5% of cases have died). Compare to the worldwide CFR and recovery rate, which has a much higher CFR (3.5%). total cases 113,432, total recovered 62,494, 55% of world-wide cases have recovered. That means SK is catching their cases through testing much earlier (which is great! This leads to both better containment and better clinical outcomes!), but it means currently they have a much higher percentage of "unresolved" cases than many other countries. We need to wait until we start seeing more recoveries in SK before we start celebrating too much. I'm optimistic that there's a good example of a strong outcome when there's a robust response in South Korea. (Data pulled from the John Hopkins global case tracker here: https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6_ https://www.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594...
- arcticbull 7y agoThe reason their numbers are lower than elsewhere is the widespread testing is catching the low-grade infections, the asymptomatic and the so on. Those cases are not reflected in, for instance, US numbers as there hasn't been any wide-scale testing. In a huge quantity of people you wind up with sniffles, a cough or mild flu-like symptoms. They don't go in, they don't get tested, so they're left out of the denominator.
- ncallaway 7y agoThat is one factor in the low CFR, but it's far too early to say it is the only factor. It totally fails to be responsive to the low percentage of resolved cases in the South Korean numbers. If the only explanation was that they were catching far more low-grade symptoms, then we should see a lower CFR with the resolved cases rising rapidly. I hope that what you state is the case, and their CFR remains where it is while the number of recovered grows. But it's still an unknown, and we won't actually know until more data comes in.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
- speleding 7y agoI realise this sounds cruel, but the age group that's most likely to die is not the most economically productive part of the population. So even if a substantial percentage would die, that does not necessarily mean the economy would be affected by a similar percentage.
- swader999 7y agoThey have a lot of assets that would be disposed, inheritance tax, capital gains. More selling.
- tunesmith 7y agoSouth Korea's fatality rate will be somewhere between "deaths / confirmed cases" (currently around 0.7%) and "deaths / (deaths + recoveries)" (currently around 28.5%) - those numbers will eventually converge. What really matters though is to keep the raw number of confirmed cases low enough so that hospitals don't get overwhelmed. If hospitals get overwhelmed, fatality rates go up. So containment is key.
- FartyMcFarter 7y agoHow about "deaths / actual cases"? This number would be smaller than both of the ones you mentioned, unless you think that somehow all actual cases are detected.
- tunesmith 7y agoYes, that's true - although I would expect that countries with widespread easy testing would have their "confirmed cases" number get pretty close to the "actual cases" number. And "actual cases" would be the people that have the actual disease, not the people that just carry the virus. For people who are carriers but are not infected, they apparently don't want to mix those people into the numbers because that's not how other illnesses are counted either.
- edraferi 7y ago> What really matters though is to keep the raw number of confirmed cases low Sure, as long as you mean "actually slow the spread of infections through responsible personal and social choices" and not "sandbag the numbers because it looks bad for you politically."
- tunesmith 7y agoOf course, because the latter doesn't protect the hospitals from getting overwhelmed.
- allovernow 7y agoChina shut down it's economy for two months. Mecca is closed. 8% of Iranian parliament was infected as of last week and two were dead. Democratic nations are putting millions of people on lockdown overnight (see Lombardy, Italy and the 2AM press conference). This isn't the god damn flu and its irresponsible to say so at this point.
- arcticbull 7y agoIt is the flu, what's different is not the threat but our response to it. So far there have been 95,000 flu deaths since October and just shy of 4,000 nCoV-19 but nobody's shutting down China, Mecca or Italy over influenza A.
- btilly 7y agoIt is the flu, what's different is not the threat but our response to it. At current mortality rates, if this infects a good chunk of the world then we are talking about as many people dying worldwide as died during WW II. Making future projections based on past deaths without considering the appropriate epidemiological model is like being in a car hurtling at a brick wall and saying, "We will be fine, none of us are hurt yet!" It is literally the same category of mistake.
- arcticbull 7y agoNo, it's not, because the data shows us that the mortality rates are low. The sensationalist numbers reported by the media are downright negligent. Yes, in Italy, we're seeing 4% mortality rates because the folks there have on average 3X as many co-morbid conditions.
- allovernow 7y agoYeah, that's why Italy just locked down the entire country. This is the first time in recent history that the media has not been sensationalizing anything, and actually has been underreporting the danger, after ignoring the outbreak in China for a month. >because the folks there have on average 3X as many co-morbid conditions Except they're also reporting a non negligible number of young people without comorbidies requiring hospitalization. The death rate is about to skyrocket because the hospitals are reaching capacity. Even in Lombardy, which has one of some of better healthcare infrastructure, things are grave. No nation on Earth has nearly enough surge capacity to a handle 5-15% hospitalization rate which includes people in their late 20s (though rare).
- FabHK 7y agoBest study I’ve seen so far (Univ Bern, Switzerland) estimates a CFR (adjusted) for Hubei province of 1.6% (or 3.3% if symptomatic). Worse above 60 yrs, better below 40 yrs. Presumably you think Korean health care is better? Now what a about other countries? https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.04.20031104v1.full.pdf https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.04.20031104v...