3 ms·
That's not insight, that's malpractice. I mean, maybe the customers are wrong. But the broker's desire not to execute sell orders and feed a panic is absolute
by ajross 7y ago
That's not insight, that's malpractice. I mean, maybe the customers are wrong. But the broker's desire not to execute sell orders and feed a panic is absolutely self-interest, and if they're wrong (and they often are! We had a similar panic just last week that turned out not to have been "the bottom"!) then they've deliberately hurt their customers to try to protect their position in the broader industry.
And that's bad. And it's the kind of behavior we tend to see at these overheated moments where the market has gotten away from the fundamentals and all the players are trying to find "tricks" to keep the gravy train rolling.
- totalZero 7y agoI don't know a single broker or sales-trader who would intentionally reject orders from a well-meaning customer. Brokerages make money on commissions and order flow when customers trade. The author of this Bloomberg opinion article has a kind of wisenheimer sense of humor and is playing fast and loose with his comments, in an attempt to make a point about the nature of panic. Failure in moments of market stress is the worst way for a brokerage to protect its position in the broader industry, because downtime damages customer confidence (long-term income) in addition to reducing order flow (short-term income). Order flow is more valuable in moments of extreme volatility because spreads widen when the market goes nuts.
- alasdair_ 7y ago>I don't know a single broker or sales-trader who would intentionally reject orders from a well-meaning customer. It happened aplenty in 2008, when banks were rushing to offload toxic crap that they owned on to the market FIRST, and only THEN were they willing to help their customers do the same.