2 ms·
> I don't believe this holds up to scrutiny. APL as a language was made to be spoken, and it seems to have succeeded in that. Alan Perlis briefly touched on tha
by lmm 7y ago
> I don't believe this holds up to scrutiny. APL as a language was made to be spoken, and it seems to have succeeded in that. Alan Perlis briefly touched on that in a great paper,[1] and just about everyone who's worked with the language and its derivatives agrees that your statement isn't true.
The people who have worked with the language are a small and highly specialised minority of programmers, unusual in many respects. I haven't worked with APL, but I have worked with symbol-heavy Haskell-style code, and I've found that even if these operators theoretically had standardised, pronounceable names, in practice being able to talk about them was a genuine problem. If there's some special difference between APL and symbolic Haskell libraries, what is that difference?
- kick 7y agoAlan Perlis is a Turing Award-winner who helped to standardize the most influential language of all time, ALGOL, of which Go, Python, C and most languages originate. In many respects, he was closer to a Go programmer than a Haskell programmer. Haskell's symbols aren't notation, they're just scribbles. Miranda is a better comparison, but Miranda too doesn't lean hard enough. Ken Iverson literally developed APL as a way to give better lectures at Harvard. It was a verbal and handwritten language long before it was typed. It excels at it, because it was designed for it.