3 ms·
It's ironic to think that one of the main selling points of Blackberry was end-to-end security (the devices talked to an on-premises server via a dedicated mobi
by rcarmo 7y ago
It's ironic to think that one of the main selling points of Blackberry was end-to-end security (the devices talked to an on-premises server via a dedicated mobile APN which had to comply with a number of requirements), and yet its on-device security model allowed an app to take over such critical functionality _by design_.
I have a number of fun stories about RIM (I was one of the BB product managers at a telco), and this post reminded me that it might be a good time to record them for posterity... :)
- jtl999 7y agoI'd be interested in hearing about it. From the (limited) amount I do know, it seemed like BB was a mix of "security by obscurity" with some memory safety (Java) and so called "internal code audits" by RIM.
- thedance 7y agoThe security of the BlackBerry came from the fact that an organization could deploy their own data message servers, the “BES” that’s connected directly to your intranet. It was a bit vpn-like, but at the application layer. IT guys liked it because it made them feel like they were in charge, which is the main feature enterprise IT guys shop for.
- rcarmo 7y agoThis is an extremely accurate statement that can be complemented by the telco side - telcos that sold BlackBerry devices saw it as a great way to "lock in" customers in the business/corporate sector, add an extra data service to the customers' bill, and reduce the number of bandwidth-guzzling PDAs (and PCs) on the fledgeling GPRS networks (which were a far cry from the [3-5]G networks we have today). It was initially played as an exclusive (not many telcos wanted to devote APNs to manufacturers or set up the tunnelling to the BES), which helped cement that worldview. From an IT perspective again, you also had pretty decent device management (activation/restriction/lockout/wipe) features. Customers, on the other hand, loved having usable e-mail and calendaring on their pockets (and later IM, but that's part to RIM's failed attempt at going mainstream, and I do thing I will write that post soon...). Oh, and they also loved week long battery life. Sad that is now a thing of the distant past.
- amaccuish 7y agoOut of interest, how did the connection from the telcos to RIM work? Was it leased lines? I'm presuming it's this direct integration that allowed BlackBerry to push a message straight out to a device, no firewalls in the way?
- rcarmo 7y agoIt wasn’t to RIM initially. It was to customer premises via their existing infrastructure (leased lines, usually, but from the telco to the customer). Later (for consumer services) RIM became essentially a large virtual corporate customer, with traffic routed via the Internet.
- generalpass 7y ago> It's ironic to think that one of the main selling points of Blackberry was end-to-end security (the devices talked to an on-premises server via a dedicated mobile APN which had to comply with a number of requirements), and yet its on-device security model allowed an app to take over such critical functionality _by design_. While true, the initial versions of iOS and Android represented a step down in security. (BlackBerry at least encrypted the phone, by default - maybe even required?) I was always baffled that the tech media would never mention how insecure Android or iOS were.
- reaperducer 7y agoMaybe because Android and iOS came out at the same time as people were learning that Blackberry's "security" was a pastiche. In order to operate in some countries, all Blackberry traffic had to be routed through that country's government servers. It's been a long while, but I'm pretty sure that India was one such country. And at least one Middle Eastern country.
- generalpass 7y ago> Maybe because Android and iOS came out at the same time as people were learning that Blackberry's "security" was a pastiche. > In order to operate in some countries, all Blackberry traffic had to be routed through that country's government servers. > It's been a long while, but I'm pretty sure that India was one such country. And at least one Middle Eastern country. This was only related to the BlackBerry Messenger (BBM), and even then only on the standard consumer phones. The corporate servers had their own keys, IIRC. Plus, it was only for messages traversing Indian or Pakistani networks, and my memory was that BlackBerry did not hand the keys over, just answered all of their requests. Even at that, this level of encrypted communications was not otherwise widely available for consumers. The actual migration from BBM to whatever iPhone and Android were offering were downgrades. I'm not aware that BlackBerry devices were ever rooted, and they were default encrypted with 128-bit AES. The OS required users to grant permission for apps to access resources, such as GPS. This took something close to a decade to be installed and enabled by default in iOS and Android. There was a big story where 3rd-party apps installed by providers contained malware. It was a huge story run everywhere and headlines made it sound as if every single phone had this vulnerability. However, they didn't mention the vulnerability could not affect BlackBerry devices because BlackBerry had a contract with all providers that the provider could not install any software to the device. Not security-related, but a big complaint from devs at the time was that BlackBerry had so many different devices that it was very expensive to develop for. Apple, for sure, and maybe Android promised this would never happen on their platforms. Only the truly naive could believe this. My takeaway was that BlackBerry somehow pissed-off all of the tech journos and suffered appropriately. That's why they got nothing but bad press. The other thing they suffered from was this "co-CEO" nonsense. For whatever reason, it seems nearly universal that if more than one person is in charge, nobody is accountable. Edit: And something even I forget about is that prior to the Snowden releases, concerns over government snooping were only for the tin-foil hat donned black-helicopter dodging conspiracy theorists. It just wasn't on the public's radar.
- scarface74 7y agoYou mean e2e security where RIM had the keys and routinely handed them over to governments....