3 ms·
There's an interesting interview where Metcalf shares his memory of the memo. An excerpt: "Metcalfe: My mom used to say if you can’t say something nice about
by tyingq 7y ago
There's an interesting interview where Metcalf shares his memory of the memo.
An excerpt:
"Metcalfe: My mom used to say if you can’t say something nice about someone you should just hold your
tongue. But Bachrach was a not nice person. Or is for that matter; he may still be around for all I know.
He was sort of a grouchy physicist on another floor in another lab, and he read my memo. And this is a
physicist. The phrase you didn’t catch in his now famous memo -- this memo’s posted all over the world
because everyone thinks it’s a hoot that he wrote this memo -- he said the problem with Ethernet was that
it was not quantum noise limited, which is a very physicist thing to say. Of course it’s not quantum noise
limited! That wasn’t the point. But he resented the fact that we were not using every shred of bandwidth
that was capable. I told you how we decided on the clock speed. There were gigabits per second of
capacity on that cable, and we were using a pitiful few megabits of it. But he was concerned that it
wasn’t... And he did a nasty thing, and it was sort of an early lesson in nastiness, which is he wrote a
memo. He didn’t come see me. He didn’t say, “I just read your memo and I have a few questions about it”. He didn’t do that. He sent a memo to my boss’s boss accusing me of writing something that wasn’t
new and it wasn’t quantum [noise limited], completely making an idiot of himself. But it didn’t feel that way at the time. It felt kind of nasty. The next thing I know I’m in my boss’s boss’s office having to explain how this guy’s an idiot. Which he is, or was. To put it more kindly, he was from a different universe. I was in a computer science universe, he was in a physics universe. We were solving different problems and he should have minded his own business. Or at least come talk to me before sending a memo to my boss’s boss, so maybe I could save him the embarrassment. There are many places where I go where that memo is on the wall, pinned to some cubicle -- “the old Bachrach memo” -- because it’s just such a great example. Now Bachrach, I ran into him a decade or two after that unfortunate memo, whereupon he was letting it be known that he’d helped invent Ethernet. How he got there I don’t quite know, but it had something to do with this memo being really instrumental in fixing some of the early
problems with Ethernet, which is a complete hallucination."
http://archive.computerhistory.org/resources/text/Oral_History/Metcalfe_Robert_1/Metcalfe_Robert_1_2.oral_history.2006.7.102657995.pdf http://archive.computerhistory.org/resources/text/Oral_Histo...