3 ms·
Simple audio filters will have a fairly gentle roll-off above/below their cutoff. Zeroing FFT bins will brickwall the frequencies that are being removed. They s
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Simple audio filters will have a fairly gentle roll-off above/below their cutoff. Zeroing FFT bins will brickwall the frequencies that are being removed. They sound subtly different.
You can build brickwall emulated filters but they're never perfect, and you have to make a tradeoff between high latency and phase distortions/ringing.
Personally I like FFT filtering because subjectively it can sound more "vintage" than filter emulations.
It's interesting that this is being used to emulate a mechanical limitation - the limited mechanical frequency range of carbon granule microphones and small speakers.
Modern speakers have an amazing ability to record and generate a much wider frequency range from much smaller transducers.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoThere's a great plugin called "Engineer's Filter" which can do some more classical filtering (Chebychev, Cauer) to really get that vintage sound. Zero'ing an FFT bin is neat for the phase artifacts/time domain aliasing. https://www.kvraudio.com/product/engineersfilter_by_rs_met https://www.kvraudio.com/product/engineersfilter_by_rs_met
- kragen 7y agoDepends on what you mean by “simple”. If you want a circuit you can build with one op-amp and some passives from some coefficients you have memorized, without simulating it first, you're probably going to go with a second order Butterworth or something and get that gentle roll-off you're talking about. But if you're using SciPy or Octave, you can synthesize a tenth-order elliptic IIR filter and apply it in three lines of code (to me that's “simple”), and it'll be pretty brickwallish. It's true that you get more latency as you move to lower-phase-distortion IIR and zero-phase-distortion FIR filters. But that's not a reason to filter in the Fourier domain instead, because in the Fourier domain you get all the latency. If you can pay all the latency that way, you can eliminate the IIR phase distortion with filtfilt. Similarly, ringing in your IIR filter is not a reason to go to the Fourier domain and start bashing bins to zero, because you get all the ringing that way: the Fourier-domain difference between your original signal and the transformed signal is a Fourier-domain impulse, whose inverse Fourier transform is a sinusoid that fills eternity. Also, just to be clear, and you probably already know this, but ringing and phase distortion are two totally different phenomena.