4 ms·
If people don't know a language, yet find it readable, they are more likely to end up getting involved in doing those things. Poor readability is not a good wa
by kazinator 7y ago
If people don't know a language, yet find it readable, they are more likely to end up getting involved in doing those things.
Poor readability is not a good way to keep people out; you're not selecting for talent.
- kick 7y agoIf the language is readable beforehand, but brings a 30% productivity decrease to those proficient in it compared to what they could have with one that wasn't, even the best programmer will be mediocre. Further, the best have had a long history of finding APL and derivatives appealing: Ken Thompson? Liked APL. Alan Perlis? Loved APL. Rob Pike? Has spent years on an APL interpreter. APL isn't lacking fantastic programmers. k has shipped with a Python-like sugar layer for years now (q). Readable to most, but without the notational value, much is lost. Q'Nial (one of my favorite programming languages) is readable by most. It's very verbose, but by all means an APL-derivative. It's not as useful a tool as one with notational benefit, and never attracted much interest. Anyone close-minded enough to ignore something entirely because they don't understand it at first isn't likely "top talent."
- neonate 7y agoYou're overestimating how readable any programming language is to non-programmers.
- saagarjha 7y agoWith decent identifiers you can kind of guess the purpose of things without understanding anything else about it. A file with words such as "latitude" and "coordinate" and "distance" in it is probably something to do with maps, for example.
- neonate 7y agoNon-programmers making sense of code in this way is extremely rare. I don't think this is a priority in programming language design, the same way that making dashboards accessible to non-pilots is not a priority in airplane design. That would certainly be a poor reason to sacrifice major improvements in airplane efficiency or safety. Designing simpler dashboards for student pilots as a learning device is of course a different matter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]