3 ms·
Forking of sites has the same problems as forking open-source projects. It exacerbates conflict, forces people to choose sides, and ultimately both forks typica
by malandrew 16y ago
Forking of sites has the same problems as forking open-source projects. It exacerbates conflict, forces people to choose sides, and ultimately both forks typically end up poorer because of members lost.
Instead, the best solution is to evolve Hacker News as a product.
My personal opinion is that we should put Hacker news in the hands of the YCombinator alumni. Founders and first employees (CEO, CTO, lead designer, first engineer hire and first design hire) of YC startups would probably make the best moderators and admins.
In fact, I would say that it's probably time that PG spin off YC as a full-time startup, assigning control of the design and codebase to one talented UI designer, one talented developer and one talented product manager.
For the site to keep growing in a way that maintains quality, it needs more functionality that it has. The two features that lack the most are filtering and combinatorial game mechanics.
Filtering is necessary so it is easy for the the hardcore tech articles to be easily found by high-karma members, so they can vote those articles up. If it's not findable, it's not voteable. Filtering is also necessary for people to extract the most value out of hacker news. Most users don't want 100 front-page articles everyday. They probably want 10-20 of the highest value articles. Less is more.
Combinatorial game mechanics like those on StackOverflow would help as well. Upvoting/downvoting is limited in that it will always fall victim to the masses. Giving special voting/tagging/burying rights to distinguished members (very high-karma users and YC founders and employees) would go a long way to helping eliminate the crap.
I think I speak for most members here, when I say that I don't want Hacker News to be a democracy. I want it to be a technocracy. I want the smart and accomplished people to control what is good and should be visible to all. I've got only 260 karma points, and personally I don't think that should be enough karma points to allow me to upvote a submission. 500+ karma points should be the threshold to be able to vote an article to the frontpage.
- Dylanlacey 16y agoEven game mechanics have a problem. Say your valued members have a certain mindset, ethos and style. Let's call it YC-meme. Everyone with YC-meme contributes in a manner that exemplifies YC-meme. If someone comes along and doesn't have that meme, their posts tend to not be what the memesters want. So, members use their voting powers to reduce that person's karma. Eventually they either leave, get ignored by all, or become infected with YC-meme. Now, open up the community to everyone. At first, YC-meme is still dominant. Only 1% of people without it are able to write posts in a style similar enough to gather karma. Let's say they have RD-meme, which has about 80% overlap with YC-meme. Great. The problem is, soon, there isn't 1% of the community with RD-meme, there's 10%. Who can (and do) re-enforce RD-meme posts, because it's what they want. People can even get lucky and simply contribute 'good' posts, long enough that they get a decent karma score, and so can re-enforce different memes. What makes it WORSE is that what's acceptible is what's visible, so with more RD-meme posts, RD-meme posts become more likely, as the probability that they get 'punished' decreases. End result: Community-dilution runaway. There are a few 'cures' I can think of, but most are fairly prescriptive: 1. A concrete set of rules and behaviors that anyone can reference to moderate from. Gross. 2. A very high bar for moderation, with active participation. Given that the people most likely to have YC-meme are also likely to be busy, this might be doomed by design. 3. "Proof" required for contribution. Great way to kill off your community. 4. Invitations. Either so easy to get as to be meaningless, or so hard as to stagnate the community. 5. Close ranks to just people at/gone from YC. Sadly, that'd mean I was out. May still be the best alternative. Maybe the community is self-aware enough to start consciously moderating better. Perhaps a post like this every so often might serve as a gentle reminder. That'd be the best outcome, but needs to be chosen by a majority of the user base. Do YOU want a stricter HN?
- silvestrov 16y ago2. A very high bar for moderation, with active participation. The reason this is doomed is: there is currently much more stuff needing moderation than the selected few can handle. They would soon wear out and you'll end up with a site with almost no moderation at all. The trash needs to be stopped at the front door. When it gets into the house, it takes too much effort to clean up.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoboth forks typically end up poorer because of members lost. I strongly disagree. Off the top of my head: XFree86/Xorg, Mozilla/Firefox, Debian/Ubuntu, Rails/Merb... these were all cases where the existing community had calcified in some key area and a fork was necessary to create a space where important work could get done. And in most of those cases, not only was the fork stronger than the trunk in (some) specific areas, the fork actually led to the trunk getting stronger. Not only were patches merged, but entire projects, community values, development practices, etc were. XFree86 is an exception, but organizational paralysis was what necessitated the fork, so it's not surprising they were also unable to respond to the fork. But I just don't buy your notion that forking is somehow unhealthy and destructive. It's one of the most valuable ways we have to keep open source code, ideas, organizations and practices fresh, healthy, and vibrant.
- malandrew 16y agoI agree that there are exceptions. In the case of HN, I don't see how forking would be of benefit, especially since HN is so strongly linked to YCombinator, the startup incubator/school that tends to attract the most talented up-and-coming startups.