3 ms·
The most interesting bit seems to be that these boxes are claimed to be more efficient than gas fired power-plants. I find that very hard to believe, but it wou
by adrianN 7y ago
The most interesting bit seems to be that these boxes are claimed to be more efficient than gas fired power-plants. I find that very hard to believe, but it would be great. Perhaps they don't take into account using waste heat for district heating or something like that.
Making Methane is a promising storage technology for excess renewable energy. Bootstrapping R&D into a more efficient way of turning Methane back into electricity with a few billion dollars doesn't seem to be the worst use of money.
- qchris 7y agoI'd definitely have to look into the actual chemistry of the process, but I don't find that claim terribly outlandish on principle. Most combustion plants end up having decent efficiency (as you mentioned) because of their access to heavy stationary insulation materials and co-generation/waste heat reclamation, but one way or another, they still end up running into the Carnot efficiency limit for heat engines. Since fuel cells operate electrochemically, they don't have that same limit, which means their theoretical efficiencies are often higher (and the ability to get somewhat near those efficiencies track as well). I'm not sure if they're comparing to full-size plants or not, but the differences between the two tend to be more pronounced as size and weight of generator decrease, since heavy insulation and waste re-use are more difficult, but fuel cells stay (somewhat) the same. I certainly agree with your observation about methane being an interesting path forward for storage technology for excess renewables, though.