8 ms·
Ah yes, the cycle of website life. * Hot new community forms at Site X. * Site X residents refer to themselves as the New Wave of whatever. Much better than o
by jacques_chester 16y ago
Ah yes, the cycle of website life.
* Hot new community forms at Site X.
* Site X residents refer to themselves as the New Wave of whatever. Much better than older Site W because of features/members/dynamic/demographics 1, 2 and 3!
* Site X's reputation spreads to former hot new sites T, U, V and W. Site X begins to attract more and more new users.
* Site X denizens begin linking articles at T, U, V, W and vice versa.
* Site X begins to exhaust natural topics of conversation. Denizens of more than 3 months standing become sick of 100th
"What does Site X think about AlphaGamma?" post and begin to slap down newbies.
* Someone reminisces out loud about the Golden Days of Site X.
* Discussions on Site X become more and more about Site X. Extremely intelligent individuals begin to earnestly argue that their proposed feature will save Site X from itself.
* Someone proposes or launches Site Y. A how new community begins to form there ...
I've been watching this same story play itself out since Slashdot circa 1998.
- tptacek 16y agoThis comes across as snide. Slashdot circa 2011 is largely unreadable. So is Digg, so is main Reddit. The cycle may be real, but so is the phenomenon driving it.
- jacques_chester 16y agoSure. All sites experience regression to the mean[1]. Usually this starts happening about 12 months after I decide to become a regular. In HN's case I've come in halfway through the cycle, about 3 months ago, so apparently the magnitude of my destructive powers is increasing. [1] and also the snide.
- JonnieCache 16y ago>I've been watching this same story play itself out since Slashdot circa 1998. And every social subculture in history. See: the constant evolution of the social scenes around music genres. It's just a fact of social psychology we have to live with. "Dubstep was sooo good back in 02 before the students found out about it! I mainly go to future-garage raves now man..."
- mkr-hn 16y agoAnd Linux was so cool before the Ubuntu kids showed up.
- jacques_chester 16y agoGood point. On reflection it resembles flocking behaviour. I imagine that website members can be modelled as simple agents with two rules: 1. A cool site has few, impressive members. 2. Move towards the cool sites. Given an arbitrary distribution of "impressive" members, this should cause a constantly moving flock of members to move from site to site regardless of its purpose.
- JonnieCache 16y agoAdd to that: 3. A member's threshold of minimum community coolness below which they will leave, is correlated to their impressiveness.
- jacques_chester 16y agoI figured I'd covered that in rule 1, but upon inspection, it's really two different rules. Your rule 3 is a better statement of one of them.
- groby_b 16y agoIt strikes me that a logical step to prevent #2 is "allow only new contributing members that have been vouched for by n old members". Yes, I'm that elitist. And yes, I'm well aware I probably wouldn't get voted in :) But here's the other part - keep the site open for reading. That means it (hopefully) self-selects for quality, and other people can observe a high-quality discussion.
- mkr-hn 16y agoDo you have any examples of a site where treehousing has improved things?
- mikeleeorg 16y agoOn reading this, the Evaporative Cooling effect comes to mind. http://blog.bumblebeelabs.com/social-software-sundays-2-the-evaporative-cooling-effect/ http://blog.bumblebeelabs.com/social-software-sundays-2-the-...
- cletus 16y agoWhile I basically agree with you--I too have seen this cycle many times before--what I don't understand is why people feel the need to slap down newbies in an attempt to recapture some since-passed golden age. If I get bored of a site or simply get nothing more out of it, I just move on. If I see topics that are boring or simply have no interest to me, I just ignore them. If I see rude, insulting comments or personal attacks, I just flag them and move on. I really don't understand why people need to express so much hate.
- jacques_chester 16y agoLoss aversion, maybe?
- jdp23 16y agoPeople who are deeply invested in a site want to defend their view of how it should be. Change is threatening, and it's easy to react with knee-jerk hostility.
- jedsmith 16y agoSlapping down newbies takes on a lot of forms, too. This entire submission and the accompanying threads comprise a giant screw-you to relative newbies like myself. I don't kid myself that I'm the kind of person that always remains civil in discussions, because I'm passionate about what I believe in. I know I'm hit-or-miss here, and often the way I communicate my point of view dilutes it and comes across as being a dick. I get that, and I've learned a lot about how to communicate with others from HN and other Web sites. If I'm the problem, though, which this submission and other comments seem to want me to believe, then I'm wondering what the solution is. Agree all the time? The burden is on me to improve, not the community to avoid me. Every time I see a navelgazing submission like this I'm yanked right out of the community and I'm instead thinking about the community instead of the topics that I come to Hacker News to read and discuss. What people don't seem to understand about community sites such as this one is that if you are discussing the community ad infinitum, you've already lost. A bunch of high-karma users, and one commenter in particular reminding us that "on behalf of the elites, this site sucks now due to you," is exactly the kind of thread that is contributing to the problem. If the high-karma users here really want a walled, invitation-only garden where a circlejerk of valley gossip takes place and everybody agrees with each other, this is a pretty good way to go about it. It's really disappointing, to be honest.
- lionhearted 16y ago> Site X begins to exhaust natural topics of conversation. Denizens of more than 3 months standing become sick of 100th "What does Site X think about AlphaGamma?" post and begin to slap down newbies. This implies it's hostility to "old hat discussions" that have already been around the block that people are worried about. I don't think that's primarily it. The civility levels have slipped a lot... this place used to be as civil and friendly as meeting a bunch of people at a dinner party where everyone admires the host. Still super-civil compared to the rest of the internet, but the levels have come down a lot. Raw outrage, profanity, and outright insults used to get downvoted to oblivion even if people agreed with the general argument the commentor was making. Rudeness really wasn't tolerated, so new members learned quickly that you had to think for a minute longer before replying. It's still a great site, but it's not elitism and reminiscing that the old guard is scared of. It's comment quality slipping to rest-of-internet level.
- derefr 16y agoHow about, instead of a single community, the site runs as a set of "cohort" communities that each only allow direct sign-ups for their first year in existence, but then run a bit like leagues thereafter? If people like you on HN/2011, you might be invited into HN/2010, then HN/2009, etc. It could also be automatic/karma-based: if you earn enough karma on HN/2011, you start again on HN/2010 with 1 karma point (though you can also stay on HN/2011, marked as an alumnus/boddhisattva.
- malandrew 16y agoPretty interesting idea. Has anything like this ever been tried with other communities?
- JonnieCache 16y agoI think this would just breed resentment, or at worst Lord Of The Flies/Robbers Cave style anarchy. [1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Realistic_conflict_theory#The_Robbers_Cave_Experiment https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Realistic_con...
- derefr 16y agoWhen you have two groups that have no reason to not be the same group, the fact that they're separated breeds resentment. When you tell them that there's a criteria they were ranked upon to put them into these groups (in this case, age + karma), they understand. For example, there's no big rivalry between grad students and undergrads; one graduated to become the other.
- JonnieCache 16y ago>For example, there's no big rivalry between grad students and undergrads; one graduated to become the other. All undergraduates know that they will soon be at least graduates, if not later postgrads. The transition is inevitable. Any kind of stratified internet community would have to have the eventual prospect of transfer from one strata to the other, as an inevitable consequence of good/bad participation. As soon as it becomes set in stone, or the transfer becomes a deliberate choice rather than an inevitable consequence of behaviour, I think people will forget about the criteria that originally divided them and slowly regress to hatred of the other.
- malandrew 16y agoJust because this has been the typical website lifecycle in the past, doesn't mean that it has to be the typical website lifecycle in the future. We increasingly have better and better tools to manage how people interact with sites and communities. Upvoting/downvoting, filtering, disemvoweling, moderation, tagging, reputation systems, etc. are just a smattering of the tools we have available and with time it's likely that we will see more and better tools for community management available in the future. The most important thing is for "us" to define exactly what current and past features of the community we want to preserve and also decide what kind and amount of "chaos" we want to permit to allow the site to evolve and improve. It makes the most sense for PG, YC founders and very high-karma users to be responsible for defining these community characteristics, ideals and values.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoThe problem is that many of those tools are affected negatively by the regression to the mean as well. An average comment, that would never be upvoted during the early elite, will be upvoted by average people during the mean. Reputation follows.
- malandrew 16y agoThe question to be answered then is "what mechanisms of reputation and combinatorial game mechanics can prevent regression towards the mean?" I don't have an answer to this off the top of my head, but succinctly describing the problem as you just did oftentimes can be half the battle.
- jacques_chester 16y agoAnother formulation: "What system can allow a site to absorb N new users without causing regression to the mean, with the constraint the membership is open?" I'm pretty sure the answer is: no such system exists.
- repsilat 16y agoEigenvalue/SVD upvoting. Comments and articles are ranked for you according to their ranking with similarly voting/submitting/commenting users. The frontpage (depending on how you set it up) could look like Reddit's, based on the majority of users, but to logged-in users it'd be more refined to their tastes. Perhaps you could look at the site from others' perspectives. Defining the model, computing likenesses and finding the appropriate material could be quite resource intensive if you didn't think long and hard about the implementation. (You'd might also want to avoid up and down arrows, because "like" and "dislike" quickly supplant "good comment" and "bad comment".)
- redthrowaway 16y agoInterestingly, this isn't a problem related to any particular category of site. Hell, look at 4chan: bitching about newfags and how /b/ isn't good anymore, how /b/ was never good, different factions with different ideas on how to fix the problem (or what the problem is, or if there even is one), spinoff sites where the early adopters migrate to... This isn't an HN problem, it's an Internet problem. pg could probably do some things to ward off dilution, but it won't last forever. Interestingly enough, Something Awful seemed to be pretty damned successful in this regard by doing the unthinkable and charging people to post there. I'd hate to suggest it as a solution, but it has been effective in the past.
- stcredzero 16y agopg could probably do some things to ward off dilution, but it won't last forever. I think a paraphrase of this sentence has appeared in HN comments 100's, perhaps 1000's of times.
- allenbrunson 16y agoyep. and in all this time, pg has managed to keep the site hovering just above the shark, as he once put it.
- astrange 16y agoSA has internal problems too. There's a constant slow cycle where the individual topic forums become boring and straightlaced because the users get proud of how mature they are, so they start new subforums where people are allowed to make "bad" but interesting posts as long as they pretend to be doing it ironically. Then everyone moves into those and it collapses, because they really did become bad posts. Sometimes they move offsite instead, usually because the site admins didn't actually like the topic enough to make more forums for them, or because the admins banned all the users because they had formed secret IRC cabals conspiring against them. The last stage is that the admins change the forum CSS so it's unreadable. I haven't figured out that part yet.
- cmaggard 16y ago
- psyklic 16y agoI wonder how different the website lifecycle is from the cycle of nightlife hotspots.
- kaffiene 16y agoHeh. Noob! Slashdot was cool in 96! Just joking! I totally agree with you. Both in regards to /. but also with websites in general. In fact, the Internet in general. It started out (for me) idealistic and cool and slowly has got dumber and more mass market as normal people started using it. Ah well. We lost something, we gained something. The cool is gone, but there's a lot more of the typical stuff and the Internet is making some of the real world changes I hoped it would only because it is now so ubiquitous (like the change in the Middle East) I think all discussion sites struggle to identify quality discussion. The whole Karma idea that /. created was very very cool and has worked reasonably well over the years. Certainly, their discourse is wildly better than digg's, for example, and I would submit that Karma is a large part of that. But the problem with Karma is that it promotes group-think and that's where /. is today. Alhough: you could say just the same about HN. Anyone who doesn't love LISP, Python & PG is automatically on the outer. Hating Java is cool, too. Perhaps group-think is an inevitable requirement for communities to form? Perhaps without some level of shared unquestioned axioms, groups will not form in the first place - just in the way a Christian and an Atheist can struggle to have a conversation about right and wrong because their starting assumptions are just so far apart? I don't know - I'm not sure if there is an answer to this kind of thing, I think that maybe it is just human nature at work.
- sophacles 16y agoI agree. One thing tho that never seems to come up: we people from older waves ignore the fact that we spent the last $N years growing, getting better, getting deeper into stuff, while the site has not grown with us. So even if the site hasn't changed, our perception of the topics and such has -- intro to X used to be deep, since we were little, but now that we are big, we just see a puddle :)
- A1kmm 16y agoIf you are right, a website could automate the cycle as follows: 1) Every user belongs to at most two (or k) classes. 2) Each class can have a finite number of users n. 3) When a class fills up, a new one is opened. 4) There are always two (or k) open classes at a time, and new users join both of those two (or k) classes. 5) The classes are staggered so they don't close at the same time; e.g. if k=2, n=10000, the first 5000 people to join belong to class 1 and class 2, the next 5000 belong to class 2 and class 3, the next 5000 to class 3 and class 4, and so on. 6) Users can only post to classes they are in, and can only comment on posts in classes they are in (or maybe newer ones too). 7) By default, users only see posts to classes they are in (or maybe their classes + older ones). They can opt in to see more if they want. The idea might work better if it is combined with some more onerous mechanism to join classes late - a fee, a requirement for an endorsement from a member or someone. Charging a fee for access to the more '1337' earlier classes might be a good way to monetise the site; the fees could either be flat, or could escalate (exponentially?) with the age of the class and / or the number of people who pay to join it late (possibly with a discount applied as active members leave). Classes might get too small due to attrition - coalescing older classes when they get too small might be a solution to this - it might also make sense to increase class sizes (exponentially?) as the site gets more popular.