4 ms·
No. Just no. I've removed all of the microdata from the web sites I manage. I'm not giving Google any information for free. Google uses microdata to show in
by reaperducer 7y ago
No. Just no.
I've removed all of the microdata from the web sites I manage. I'm not giving Google any information for free.
Google uses microdata to show information from web sites without people actually visiting the site. Google gets free labor. Publishers get squat. Adding microdata to content pages consolidates information with Google, hurting everyone else.
Google has billions of dollars to spend on scraping and searching and whatever it wants to do. It could mechanical turk the entire internet if it wanted.
I am not Google's free labor.
- ZenPsycho 7y agomicrodata and microformats aren’t the same thing.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoOk, but what's the difference in relation what the parent poster said? You go through the trouble of adding microformats to your site you are helping Google analyze that site and potentially present data from that site without you ever going there. However microformats potentially help others, because of Google's actions it is to a site owner's benefit to not provide beneficial metadata past a certain point, assuming of course they want visits provided by Google.
- ZenPsycho 7y agoOn the off chance that you're adding microformats to your site in good faith rather than just trying to make it accessible to google, there are non google tools, utilities, search engines, applications, browser extensions and so on that make use of the microformat data, to, for instance provide "add to calendar" buttons to marked up events, or automatically convert an html blog to an rss feed. I don't know if they ever got there but there was a vision to have a standard markup for shopping cart items so browser extensions could assist with price comparisons.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoThat's my point exactly, if you are adding microformats to your site in good faith because you believe it is the best thing for the web and enables peoples tools to work with your site better, google penalizes you by reducing your site traffic and increases their sites utility for users, effectively increasing their profits off of your labor while starving you at the same time.
- ZenPsycho 7y agoi don’t know how your hosting plan works, but on every plan I’ve looked at, traffic costs money. if your web based business depends on traffic to serve advertising, then no, you’re not doing it in good faith to make the web better.
- anoncake 7y agoI don't think stores want to facilitate price comparisons.
- ZenPsycho 7y agodepends on which store you are in the comparison
- bawolff 7y agoIf you really want to stick it to google, you can always put a robots.txt file with disallow: * directive. But you probably don't. Presumably because you rely on google to direct users to your website. I find it hard to claim that publishers get squat out of this arrangement when google is probably the primary method relevant users find your content. Which to be clear, I'm not saying that website operators have any sort of duty to assist third parties in extracting just the useful part of their website. They obviously don't. They can make their website however they feel like. I just don't think the disdain of google over the practice of extracting and redisplaying content provided in a format explicitly for the purpose of letting people do that, is warranted. If you don't want to opt-in, that's fine, but google is doing nothing wrong by using data provided to the world for the general purpose of enabling them to do exactly what they are doing.
- reaperducer 7y agoPresumably because you rely on google to direct users to your website. You presume incorrectly. The sites I'm talking about have no advertising. They are not ad-supported. They do not rely on Google or any other search engine in any way. There are other business models.
- bawolff 7y agoSure. Many of those business models still rely on people finding your site (although there are exceptions)
- anoncake 7y agoWould Google penalize you for showing microdata to everyone but googlebot without changing anything else?