2 ms·
I'll vouch for Walter, even if his insight I've received less than coolly in the past. He is technically correct that the pilot's did have information in hand
by salawat 7y ago
I'll vouch for Walter, even if his insight I've received less than coolly in the past.
He is technically correct that the pilot's did have information in hand through Airworthyness Directives at the time. The only place I tend to depart from him point of view-wise is how the human factors come into it.
He believes, (and if you mull on it from the technical point of view, he's right) that it should have been covered with the same procedure.
I may not be an aero engineer, but I've done stints in both Quality, and Safety industries. My stint in safety brought me into contact frequently with the aviation guys, and unintuitively enough, they were very particular about how information was presented to pilots. When I asked why, th He answer was that they needed to fly the plane, not be burdened with how everything went together. Their job was seen as needing to know everything that affected the operation and aeronautic behavior of the craft first and foremost.
That's where I believe these Airworthyness Directives, though accurate, failed. The pilot's mental model was built up during their training period which included no mention of MCAS. The Airworthyness Directive in this case would translate to informing a pilot of a Major feature release through an off hand set of patch notes.
Which is why I still hold Boeing at fault, even if a faulty misunderstand may have been arrived at by the pilot's reading alone of a notification outlining the exact solution to the feature.
You don't build the kind of instinctual multi-level reflexive behavioral binding through a singular notification. You must explain the why, and provide repeated examples to get good retention.
- WalterBright 7y agoI tend to agree with you. But I've never been happy operating machinery I did not understand, but was just pushing buttons because the manual said so. For an example, I've taken cars completely apart and put them back together. Knowing how they work has enabled me to get a lot more out of my car than others can. Doubtless knowing how an airplane flies and how all the systems work will make for a better pilot in times of crisis. I think back on all the times Neil Armstrong got himself out of a jam through such understanding (he was an engineer, too).