5 ms·
> Truck driver. Not quibbling, just adding nuance. You're absolutely quibbling though. > So you should include in your calculations that the load is spread ou
by masklinn 7y ago
> Truck driver. Not quibbling, just adding nuance.
You're absolutely quibbling though.
> So you should include in your calculations that the load is spread out over eighteen tires, as above.
The fourth power rule is specifically about axle load, not about wheel load. It's also an estimate / rule of thumb (which is why it's so useful), not a precision instrument.
But hey if you want more precision than the FPR we can do more precision: https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/design-parameters/equivalent-single-axle-load/ https://pavementinteractive.org/reference-desk/design/design...
As the link notes, road engineers usually work in LEF/ESAL (ratio to a standardised 18000lbs axle load), and provides some conversion tables.
Assuming a relatively large 4000lbs sedan this is 2000 lbs per axle, or 2x0.0003 LEF = 0.0006 LEF.
A fully loaded truck would be ~0.3 for the 12000lbs front axle, and 1.11 for each of the rear tandem axles, for a total of 2.52 LEF.
2.52 / 0.0006 = 4200. Which shows that the fourth power rule's 4096 was pretty close but if anything underselling it.
- jessaustin 7y agoYeah, they use dual tires so that they don't pop catastrophically, not to spare the road from wear.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoI'm sure that's true, but are you saying it doesn't reduce wear?
- masklinn 7y agoI'm sure it reduces wear on the tires.
- reitzensteinm 7y ago"The AASHTO load-equivalency factors strictly apply only to axles supported at each end by dual tires. Recent increase in steering-axle loadings and more extensive use of single tires on load-bearing axles have precipitated efforts to examine the effect on pavement wear of substituting single for dual tires." https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/reports/tswstudy/TSWwp3.pdf https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/reports/tswstudy/TSWwp3.pdf
- jessaustin 7y agoIt probably reduces wear slightly. Increasing contact area necessarily decreases applied pressure. Then again, a wider effective contact profile damages more of the road than a narrower one would. Let's not forget the context of this discussion, however. Fourth power expressions are still fourth power expressions after multiplication by a constant factor. 4/18 is a constant factor.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoYou're multiplying the input by a constant factor. If wear is proportional to (weight per tire)^4, and you've halved weight per tire by having twice as many, you've just reduced wear to 6% of its original value. I don't know if doubling tire counts really does this, but it's hard to see why twice as many axles would help but tires per axle would not. It's possible (the pressure underneath the tires is reduced, but the tires exerting pressure on the road are closer together) but counter intuitive to say the least. And there's no proof in this thread that it doesn't help except for masklinn's misinterpretation of the original study.
- jessaustin 7y agoAlso, road wear is a function of friction as well as pressure. Friction is increased with additional tires.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoThis is already taken in to account with the forth power rule, isn't it?
- reitzensteinm 7y agoFourth :)
- a3n 7y agoThat's been the benefit to me, still having a drivable rig when a tire shreds. But, there is also something called a "super single" that's a double wide single wheel/tire, with one on the end of an axle rather than two. I'm told they're cheaper and lighter total, as opposed to the more common two per end. I've pulled a few trailers that had them. I don't really know why one or the other, I just drive them.
- a3n 7y ago> The fourth power rule is specifically about axle load, not about wheel load. Misunderstood that, sorry.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoNo, parent is mistaken. The forth power rule bakes in an assumption of dual tires at each end of an axle.