5 ms·
My feeling is that if you really wanted the author to improve, you would try to connect personally, establish trust and then talk to them privately about ways y
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
My feeling is that if you really wanted the author to improve, you would try to connect personally, establish trust and then talk to them privately about ways you feel they could improve their writing. And maybe you aren't comfortable reaching out privately because it's a woman, so that could go sideways (assuming you are male, which I don't actually know). Let me assure you that if you have good intentions, publicly dogging someone because you aren't comfortable reaching out privately is not a good substitute.
Seeing this comment at the top of the page on the highest ranked post on the HN front page for the only woman programmer that I am personally aware of who regularly makes the front page really feels like a kick in the gut and looks like sexist garbage. And I would like to think better of HN than that.
- Misdicorl 7y agoWholeheartedly agree with this. I expected to see the parent comment, but I'm really sad to see it at the top. Of course that's not the commenters fault per se; it's clearly a very common opinion people are happy/eager to communicate rather than be ashamed of (even if so mildly as to prefer not to have it in their upvote collection).
- losteric 7y agoI agree that the previous post was not constructive or effective, but there's nothing sexist about what they said. It's just someone broadcasting critical opinion.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 7y agoHow is this sexist? Treating the author differently based on sex is garbage. A male author would receive exactly the same public treatment.
- Misdicorl 7y agoPolicing tone is far more prevalent when the speaker is a woman. Perhaps (I'm doubtful) this feedback would be given to a very well known male speaker, but it would not have been the top comment here.
- type0 7y agoIt's a good rant, but it's still a rant. Don't make it to something it's not, plenty of rants get harsher critiques and or don't receive that much up-votes.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoCriticism is a staple of any human discussion/forum. It's not even feedback, it's just complaining about TFA. Sometimes the top comment on HN is someone complaining about the font-color of the blog post. Let's not lose our minds here. Seems weird to get worked up over spotting a complaint on HN just because a woman wrote TFA. And btw, most complaints on HN are leveled at men simply because men populate this forum and tech more than women. Does that mean this forum hate men? Why is it assumed men can handle it but women can't? I have to wonder how many women are turned off by the idea that they need to be babied like this and can't take generic online criticism. Or the suggestion that criticism was only leveled at them because they are women. It sure reeks, to me.
- Misdicorl 7y agoThe type of criticism matters. A lot. It's not about babying women. It's about pointing out different standards for different speakers.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoHaving different standards for different speakers is exactly what you're doing. Criticizing how a message is delivered is standard HN criticism. Especially the sort of "everyone is smart except for me" tone of TFA. I myself criticize commenters here for that as it's something I can't stand, either. Why would you think it's something we only see leveled at women here? And, according to what? And, yes, you're then infantilizing women when OP does receive that criticism. I think your heart is in the right place, but you're doing exactly what you think you're condemning.
- Misdicorl 7y ago
- bluntfang 7y agoI'd be interesting to get the sentiment on Torvold's history of blog posts that make hacker news. Willing to bet my paycheck that his sarcastic and ranty tone was loved.
- toxik 7y agoOtoh she isn’t him, he’s famous.
- nostrademons 7y agoThis is the Internet, where you take whatever feedback you get with the appropriate grain of salt and either choose to improve or not. Most people on the public venues on the Internet - forums, blogs, comments, essays - are not looking to build relationships or establish trust. (There are some exceptions - I've made some great friendships with Internet friends - but they're usually more private niche forums than blogs or other publications with a wide readership.) They're looking to get their opinion out there, build a readership, perhaps influence public discourse, and maybe get some feedback on their ideas. I've seen similar comments leveled at PG [1] and Zed Shaw [2], so I don't think it's just sexism. [1] https://idlewords.com/2005/04/dabblers_and_blowhards.htm https://idlewords.com/2005/04/dabblers_and_blowhards.htm [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9275526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9275526
- Misdicorl 7y agoNote that both your examples are a) criticising content rather than delivery/tone b) not the primary conversation around these two authors Look to Linus Torvalds for a male example where delivery rather than content is often the primary conversation. That is how egregious the delivery must be for a male to get the tone police called on them
- nostrademons 7y agoYou may have something there. I went looking for the HN comments on Dabblers and Blowhards [1] (which, IMHO, is even more egregiously sanctimonious than Rachel's essay), but the top comment there was responding to content rather than tone. Only the 3 bottom-most comments remarked on tone. I don't consider Linus Torvalds that vitriolic, BTW. Most of the time when he's angry he's trying to make a point. I think of Erik Naggum [2] or Poul Henning-Kemp when it comes to real vitriol on the Internet. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=238325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=238325 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1472002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1472002
- asveikau 7y agoPeople have valid criticisms of Linus's delivery, but the content is often good. I tend to remember some of the technical arguments in those rants years after the fact, and cite them. Keep in mind he did create the Linux kernel and git, so even if he delivers them inexpertly, even on a bad day, he has some technical insight. All that said: I agree there is some gender bias showing up on this thread.
- diebeforei485 7y agoIt's not about "wanting the author to improve". People are free to write on their own personal blog with as much snark as they like, in whatever style they prefer. However, what seems to have happened here is that a bunch of folks are upvoting this link to the top of HN because of who the author is. Meanwhile, other HN readers find this particular post to be a waste of time because, frankly, the content of the post itself is not particularly interesting or useful for most HN readers. Other posts[1][2] by this author have been much better suited for the top of HN, for example [1] https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2018/04/23/pace/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2018/04/23/pace/ [2] https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2019/11/18/oldbash/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2019/11/18/oldbash/
- Rapzid 7y agoI think that kinda hits the nail on the head. For a lot of people on HN the information being presented in the posts isn't new or particularly insightful. So to read the information presented in a tone where the author believes they are the only ones with the "true knowledge" can be very off-putting. But of course there are other people that may get more out of it and not have a negative reaction to it.
- irrational 7y agoWow. You really had to go there with the sexism, didn’t you?
- blast 7y agoDoreenMichele is actually much less ideological than most. Maybe it's not obvious from this thread, but those of us who have read her in that past know that her thoughts on these topics are actually unpredictable (and in particular, not at all anti-men). That's quite unusual. I'd give her the benefit of the doubt.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dmurray 7y agoMuch less ideological than most what? Most women who call attention to them being women on the Internet? Or just most people who post interesting technical stuff online?
- blast 7y agoThan most people who comment about gender issues on the internet. I find that once you have a few bits of information, you can nearly always predict where someone is going to come down on such matters. It's not common to run into someone who's less predictable that way.
- defterGoose 7y agoWhat you're saying with this post and the one below is that criticizing a woman (even in a situation where women are underrepresented) is sexist. This is obviously not true and if you believe the criticism is unwarranted then you should make your own criticism based on those points.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat's not what I'm saying at all and it's dumbfounding to me that I am getting such a pile on to try to shut me up by probably all men trying to claim there's no sexism here. My framing actually assumes positive intent gone wrong and suggests that if there is positive intent, this is not a best practice. Entire audience hears "Some whiny bitch reading in sexism where there is none and that needs to be shut down cuz reasons." And therein lies the problem. But I promised myself I wasn't going to be dragged into some shitshow. I knew no matter how carefully I worded it, it was likely to get ugly pushback and not get good faith engagement. So I'm out of here. Thanks.