3 ms·
cheap medical for those that can't afford it, homeless shelters for the less fortunate, build more houses so that houses are cheaper, cheap education. I'm all
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
cheap medical for those that can't afford it, homeless shelters for the less fortunate, build more houses so that houses are cheaper, cheap education.
I'm all for cheap medical and build more houses. I think that would go a long way towards resolving the housing issue in the US.
I've had a college class on Homelessness and Public Policy and I spent nearly six years homeless. I blog about it.
It's routine for people to reiterate the same tired point of view that "It's all crazies and junkies and more housing won't solve it." Quoting data that increases in housing costs correlates to about 96% of the increase in homelessness and people still insist they're version of events is the one true explanation.
I'm not denying there's a lot of drug use and mental health issues on the street. But both of those are actively fostered by homelessness and there are millionaire rock stars who are in and out of rehab, so it's really not accurate to pretend that addiction is done kind of root cause explanation. It's just not that simple and the mantra of "junkies and crazies" mostly gets used to act like it's an unsolvable personal issue and not a systemic issue.
Our housing issues are rooted in events that occurred at the end of WW2. Most people don't see the connection between those events, the policies that grew out of them and the debacle we currently have.
I've studied this issue for many years. I don't know how to get traction on solving it. I'm a woman and I was homeless for years. Sexism and classism close a lot of doors in my face while people basically sit around listening intently to well-heeled white men repeat the usual BS as to why we can't actually fix anything.
Just an FYI for people tempted to jump up and tell me UBI is the solution: my personal opinion of UBI is that it's a puke worthy fuck you that intentionally and with malice aforethought shits all over the poor and actively excludes them from the halls of power. So let's just skip that part of the conversation. I'm not sympathetic.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoLet's say you had unlimited funds - just as a thought experiment - would you have a solution then?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoPossibly not because so much of it is political, for lack of a better word. I would like to see housing policy changed in this country and I would like to see us solve the healthcare stuff. If I had unlimited funds, I would make a go of building SROs/microunits and Missing Middle Housing as a real estate developer. This country has torn down about a million SROs in recent decades and largely zoned out of existence the ability to build Missing Middle Housing, which used to be a common form of housing. New Urbanism was an attempt to build walkable neighborhoods. It wasn't wildly successful in bringing back historical patterns of neighborhood development and became mostly enclaves of nicer homes for upper class Americans. It faced a huge uphill battle in getting anything built at all and it was apparently common for developers and architects to take their New Urbanist neighborhood plan to the city, get it declined and then comb through the building codes and regulations and rename a bunch of stuff on their map while making little to no changes. Then take it to the city again. Rinse and repeat until they got approval of something vaguely similar to their initial vision. The new version of this is YIMBYism. What little I have seen of YIMBYism is political stuff and I am mostly not seeing them bring answers as to what kind of housing works well, what kind of financing works well, etc. They seem to just campaign for "more housing in my town" and that seems to be it, which has potential to go all kinds of bad places. If I had both money and power, I would wave my magic wand and bring back walkable neighborhoods full of Missing Middle Housing (and SROs) that even ordinary joes can afford and I would move this country to single payer healthcare. And then I would go on vacation for the rest of my life, having done enough to feel satisfied with my life.
- chadcmulligan 7y ago> If I had both money and power, I would wave my magic wand and bring back walkable neighborhoods full of Missing Middle Housing (and SROs) that even ordinary joes can afford and I would move this country to single payer healthcare. And then I would go on vacation for the rest of my life, having done enough to feel satisfied with my life. Sounds like you have a plan, here they're building a huge amount of apartments, and its keeping rents low. The other long term item I'd suggest is education, if a chunk of the population is uneducated then they're easily exploitable. The thing with education when you have a large population of working poor is that its a low priority for them. You can make education as free as you want, but when people are working 20 hours a day to live then it doesn't matter. imho its a systems problem, with the underlying issue being the lower stratum of society aren't getting enough money - even if they work, its ridiculous. Its not socialism to pay people enough to live when they work, if people only have to work one job, then they can focus on things like night school if they want, looking after they're kids so they can go to school. Again with my telescopic view from across the pond it does seem engineered to keep a class of uneducated god fearing slaves.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoEducation is a thorny issue in the US because we tend towards two tracks in a manner that makes poor people and people of color suspicious that it's propaganda and designed to intentionally keep some people oppressed. I doubt it's a system consciously designed to keep a class of uneducated God fearing slaves. I think "Never assume malice where stupidity while suffice to explain it" applies. A lot of crappy stuff genuinely is rooted in people being oblivious and unable to really see it. It's part of why stuff is so intractable: The people orchestrating it frequently feel innocent and wrongly accused.
- chadcmulligan 7y ago> A lot of crappy stuff genuinely is rooted in people being oblivious and unable to really see it. It's part of why stuff is so intractable: Indeed it's an emergent behaviour from a lot of stupid and greedy decisions of the past. I have found its a rare ability for someone to be able to stand outside themselves and see how something ended up there. Like the stuff Bernie is talking about, how it seems to be being called socialism, but over here it's just life. There are those on the extreme right that fight against it, fortunately they haven't won here, yet, imho. > I doubt it's a system consciously designed to keep a class of uneducated God fearing slaves I don't think it was designed that way, but I'd say there are people taking advantage of the status quo and quite happy to keep it that way - cheap labour is good, and there are many who enjoy feeling righteous by pointing a finger at the behaviour of those less fortunate. I suppose the question is whose advantage is it to fix it? Probably not many, it's easier to just increase the police force and keep these people in jail and prepare for the inevitable uprisings. > The people orchestrating it frequently feel innocent and wrongly accused. Yes, so there's a way to fix it working with these people, but there are forces at work fighting it now or not interested in supporting change and they have a lot of money. Think I'll get off my Sunday morning pulpit now :-)
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> Our housing issues are rooted in events that occurred at the end of WW2. Most people don't see the connection between those events, the policies that grew out of them and the debacle we currently have. Could you be a bit more specific about this? I'm not saying you're wrong, but you're not saying enough that I can tell what policies you have in mind. > Just an FYI for people tempted to jump up and tell me UBI is the solution: my personal opinion of UBI is that it's a puke worthy fuck you that intentionally and with malice aforethought shits all over the poor and actively excludes them from the halls of power. So let's just skip that part of the conversation. I'm not sympathetic. Again, I'm not saying you're wrong. But could you be a bit more specific about why you think UBI is malicious?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoWhen "the boys" came home from WW2, the nation as a whole worked together to create adequate housing -- to fulfill pent up demand at a time when there was money, etc, to do so. This was the birth of the modern suburb filled with single family detached homes. All our policies skew towards making it policy to finance and build single family detached homes and the result has been that such homes have more than doubled in size and added lots of amenities. Meanwhile, we have largely made it difficult or impossible to finance and build a lot of other housing options. Then we come up with ridiculous hacks to get around the zoning issues, like Tiny Houses on wheels instead of on a foundation because if you put it on wheels, it doesn't have to comply with size minimums we have written into law. And Tiny Houses have a lot of problems. They fail to really solve the issue and they fail in part because we aren't changing our policies to make them actually work decently. I don't wish to discuss UBI. That was the entire point of ending my comment with that disclaimer. So I'm going to stand on "I still don't really want to discuss that, thanks."
- chadcmulligan 7y agoIn Australia they're building a large number of inner city, and suburban apartments, and indeed they are doing what you suggest it seems - making rents affordable, and even purchase if you like. there are a lot of people that are against living in apartments - mainly older, but it works, and seems like a solution in Europe. The great thing about apartments is they create a close hub of people that can then be served with public transport, large suburbs you have to have a car.