3 ms·
If it changes the phenomena that trigger false-positives of suspicion towards "was actually present near the scene of the crime" and away from "wrong skin color
by shadowgovt 7y ago
If it changes the phenomena that trigger false-positives of suspicion towards "was actually present near the scene of the crime" and away from "wrong skin color in the neighborhood," it can be argued the tech has improved people's lives.
- maram 7y ago>>it can be argued the tech has improved people's lives. I have a problem with general cynicism toward technology. I believe the core problem we have with tech is all about privacy. We are on the fringe of a golden era, and we should resolve these issues about privacy and dark UX that deceive users. We don't need to "argue" whether tech improved our lives. It already did!! When did we ever in the history of mankind had the chance to communicate, and access information in real-time?!
- rak 7y agoThe problem is that it isn't. The police have routinely conducted similar dragnets with racial profiling in the past. Even in systems with less human intervention (e.g automated loan approval systems) bias is still being built in. If anything this could provide people with the excuse of "see! it was the algorithm!".
- TuringNYC 7y ago>> Even in systems with less human intervention (e.g automated loan approval systems) bias is still being built in. Just because there is bias in the system does not mean it is OK to open the floodgates and introduce more >> If anything this could provide people with the excuse of "see! it was the algorithm!". It doesn't work that way. First the person has to come up with tens of thousands of dollars to defend themselves and hire lawyers and expert witnesses. What you are stating is just a luxury of the rich. If the new system is that rich people get extra avenues of defense, you are right.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> The police have routinely conducted similar dragnets with racial profiling in the past How does the geofence-based system to determine whether you were in the area of a crime when it was committed know what race you are? I'm suggesting that in the absence of a tool like this, cops will use their eyeballs and knock on doors, and we already know that process is racially biased.