3 ms·
The third party doctrine is badly outdated in the modern world where third parties hold immense volumes of information about our locations and interactions. Si
by theluketaylor 7y ago
The third party doctrine is badly outdated in the modern world where third parties hold immense volumes of information about our locations and interactions. Since it was a court ruling that brought the doctrine into being, the passage of legislation or further court rulings can overturn it or reduce the scope. There is absolutely work for groups like the ACLU and EFF to do here.
Here in Canada several of our wireless providers banded together to fight an incredibly broad request for information about everyone hitting particular cell towers during a robbery. The crown tried to simply drop the request when challenged, but thankfully the judge didn't let them off so easily. The court issued some rather strict requirements for similar requests.
https://blog.privacylawyer.ca/2016/01/ontario-court-provides-clear-guidance.html https://blog.privacylawyer.ca/2016/01/ontario-court-provides...
- kspacewalk2 7y agoJudicial oversight requirements should be strict, but it should absolutely be a police investigation tool. Calling it "dragnet" to imply dystopian surveillance is silly. Oversight is the crux of the issue, not the tool itself.