5 ms·
'Codes' here being 'source code'. I wonder why some industries (HPC, defence) talk about code as being a discrete countable noun, where almost all other indust
by chrisseaton 7y ago
'Codes' here being 'source code'.
I wonder why some industries (HPC, defence) talk about code as being a discrete countable noun, where almost all other industries talk about code as being an uncountable mass noun.
Example: GitHub and Amazon have code, whereas Cray and Raytheon have codes.
I wonder what 'one code' looks like to them? Is it on function? One line?
- notduncansmith 7y agoMy understanding is that one code is the same as one software.
- nckthrn 7y agoIn engineering, a code can refer to a simulation package itself; eg automotive engine design software like Ricardo WAVE. To me, it always seemed to be how mechanical engineers referred to software.
- closeparen 7y agoEven in Silicon Valley, engineers write code; data scientists write codes. They tend to have postgraduate degrees, while we don’t, so it may be an academic thing.
- chrisseaton 7y agoEven in academia most people write 'code'.
- currymj 7y agoIt seems to be a shibboleth specific to numerical computing people -- ODE solvers, linear algebra algorithms, or Fortran weather simulators tend to be described as "codes". Numerical applications are the biggest part of HPC and there's probably more of it in defense as well. I've never heard it used but it seems "one code" would be one implementation of a specific algorithm from the literature -- probably one or a few functions.
- lainga 7y agoHere's a crackpot semantic theory: in their context "code" is not a continuous, uncountable bulk of text to be manipulated or examined. A "code" is a self-contained program, a discrete object which is created, distributed, and used as a tool. (Maybe decoupling and modularity is not common in numerical analysis? I don't know) So it doesn't make sense in that field to use "code" as an uncountable noun, any more than someone in 1990 would call a set of individual workstation PCs "compute" instead of "some computers".
- im3w1l 7y agoI interpret it the opposite way. It signals that they aren't part of the mainstream conversation. That they don't know what is going on outside their doors. And that they are probably not aware of the last 30 years best practices.
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoIt sure is a shame that people working on magnetohydrodynamic simulations aren't part of the same conversation as the people writing advertising code in javascript. Imagine all the best practice in scrum and agile that they've missed out on.
- glouwbug 7y agoWell, those guys are building something vastly more complex than advertising software, possibly without agile and scrum, and they deliver high stake working software. Likewise, I've seen agile purists deliver totally broken login screens. The difference, in my opinion, lies in the software's end goal; software you write for a NASA space flight might kill the astronaut you've met at NASA. Software you write for a login screen won't, as it's not as high stake. You're probably going to put on your head phones, pick a YouTube playlist, scroll through JIRA, and meme around on slack. We've evolved thousands of years fighting real physical threats, and we have implemented processes to deal with these physical threats in order to survive. A JIRA ticket for a broken login screen just does not trigger the same brain pattern response as your astronaut friend burning to death during orbital re-entry.
- _bxg1 7y agoWhen I see "codes" I generally assume it means passcodes/keys of some kind (especially in this case with the word "key" beforehand)
- chrisseaton 7y agoIt's not 'key-codes', it's 'codes (source code) that are key', in this article. It later says 'Israel’s refusal to provide the US military with Iron Dome’s source code.'
- _bxg1 7y agoI know that, I'm just contributing to the parent comment's discussion about naming conventions.
- smcl 7y agoIt’s an easy-to-make and harmless mistake. I’m sure we do the same when we talk about stuff that isn’t software or tech
- chrisseaton 7y agoNo you're misunderstanding - it's not a mistake - I read quite a lot from HPC and they specifically talk about 'codes' in their literature. It's just how they use the word. Here's one other random example that sounds normal to HPC people and bizarre to most other industries. "Debugging parallel codes can be incredibly difficult, particularly as codes scale upwards." > https://computing.llnl.gov/tutorials/parallel_comp/ https://computing.llnl.gov/tutorials/parallel_comp/
- smcl 7y agoAh sorry, I completely mis-read your comment. That really is peculiar, I had no idea this was a thing
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoThe obvious answer is that these are extraterrestrials masquerading as people, living amongst us, writing codes for the military industry.
- warent 7y agoThis may also be related to American English vs. British English. e.g. math vs. maths
- mjlee 7y agoI'm British and "codes" sounds very odd to me in this context. Maths retains its s because it's an abbreviation of the plural noun mathematics.
- jey 7y agoWhat is a "mathematic" as a singular noun? I only know of "mathematic" as an adjective.
- thebruce87m 7y agoI’m British and we say code. “Codes” to me is like nails on a blackboard. The one place I do see “codes” consistently is Indian blogs/vlogs.
- walshemj 7y agoGood way to get your CV dropped in the bin or vice verse to have people ignore or even (put on a do not call list) a potential employer. It reads reads to me from the uk as a "How do you do, fellow kids"
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Good way to get your CV dropped in the bin or vice verse to have people ignore or even (put on a do not call list) a potential employer. Well those people would be missing out because some of the most talented scientists write 'codes'.
- walshemj 7y agoSeeing as my first job was at a world leading RnD organisation in the Math and nuke modeling department (the president of the mechanicals was the boss) I assure you I did not write "codes" nor did the Engineers
- baumatron 7y agoYou'll notice in this case only the headline refers to code as "codes." It is referred to as "source code" in the rest of the article. Probably a mistake by the editor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomc1985 7y agoOn another note, I really hate to be called a "coder". I am a programmer
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ohazi 7y ago> I wonder what 'one code' looks like to them? Is it on function? One line? One machine instruction (e.g. one opcode, three opcodes) One g-code, a list of g-codes
- walshemj 7y agoIts an import from other languages - trouble is use "codes" or god forbid "learnings" automatically marks you down as probably a c lister.
- threeseed 7y agoThe term codes I believe is what is taught at Indian universities. I have worked across US, UK and Australia and everywhere it is exclusively Indian developers who use the term codes. I still hear it every day and I don't believe anyone brings it up because technically both ways are right.
- samatman 7y agoAnother shibboleth I associate with Indian developers is "a software". They might say "I wrote a software to..." while their American counterpart would say "I wrote some software to...", would say "X is a software which does Y" rather than "X is software which does Y".
- inopinatus 7y agoPerhaps they are simply familiar with Gödel numbering and the philosophical consequences thereof