2 ms·
I buy that, but I guess to me that is what the slogan is supposed to imply, but I do agree it's not always taken that way. That is: merely not finding evidence
by _delirium 16y ago
I buy that, but I guess to me that is what the slogan is supposed to imply, but I do agree it's not always taken that way. That is: merely not finding evidence tells you nothing. However, not finding evidence, when you have a prediction of what evidence should be found, may be evidence against. So you need two things there: 1) absence of evidence; and 2) a prediction of what evidence there should've been. If all you have is #1 by itself, you have no evidence of anything. Hence, absence of evidence (without more) isn't evidence of absence.
Maybe I'm in the wrong debates, but most of the times when I see the slogan applied, the person doesn't have the second part. For example, a common elementary error is to conclude that variables are uncorrelated because you calculated their correlation in your data set and it was not significant. Failure to find a correlation in a very large population study that's large enough that it should have found one, can be evidence of no correlation (or no large correlation, at least), but you have to do a separate analysis for that.