3 ms·
The "decade with a single music genre" is much more a US thing than (say) a UK thing. The popular music scene in the UK since the 1950s at least was always divi
by PaulDavisThe1st 7y ago
The "decade with a single music genre" is much more a US thing than (say) a UK thing. The popular music scene in the UK since the 1950s at least was always divided into different genres and subcultures, many of them substantial in size and frequently with only a plurality for the largest. But I'm not even sure that the US really matches this description either. It's mostly a fiction created by mass media rather than reflecting the situation on the ground.
I was around when two "major" popular music "moments" happened (punk in London in the 1970s, and grunge in Seattle in the 1990s). It has always been striking to me just how few people were involved in these subcultures, and how hidden they were until one day they weren't. Punks in London in 1977 were a tiny, wierd, shunned group that got a lot of attention. Grunge fans in Seattle in the early 1990s had a handful of venues and a lot of people wondering why these people were wearing second hand plaid shirts.
It's even true of the hippies/counterculture at the end of 1960s/1970s. There were always far more "squares" among their generational cohort than there ever were members of that "group", which is why I get irritated with people who think that "hippies grew up and went to wall street". Not really. Maybe a few, but wall st. got populated in the 1980s by people who never were and never would have been hippies - which is to say, most of the population.
- munificent 7y ago> a lot of people wondering why these people were wearing second hand plaid shirts. When grunge spread outside of Seattle, yes. I was in New Orleans in the 90s when grunge got big and seeing people in 90°F wearing flannel was definitely odd. But in Seattle, plaid flannel has always been a thing and continues to be for entirely logical reasons: it's fucking cold and flannel is cozy and warm. You're absolutely right that at any point in time there has never been a single monolithic popular culture. Even the 60s had Burt Bacharach, Bob Dylan, the Beach Boys, and Otis Redding. It does feel to me that the transition to streaming means the genres have splintered into finer and finer subdivisions with people less and less aware of what's outside of their own personal recommendation bubble. If you listened to new wave exclusively in the 80s, you still knew about hair metal. You'd hear snatches of it as you scanned the radio. But, today, I literally have no idea what other people are listening to and I'm fairly certain no one around me knows about all the weird niche stuff I listen to all day.
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoSeattle is rarely "fucking cold". It is damp in the winter, but trust me, in 1991 (say), very few people were wearing flannel (plaid or otherwise) as a main clothing choice. Fleece: check. Goretex (or equivalent): check. Flannel: bed sheets!