3 ms·
That's one way. Another way is for the government to declare and emergency and order production, and to set rules about distribution like limiting people to one
by anigbrowl 7y ago
That's one way. Another way is for the government to declare and emergency and order production, and to set rules about distribution like limiting people to one box at a time or whatever. Markets are typically closer to economic optimality over the longer run but not in the short term, and furthermore optimality is not always that important for many commodities that can be stockpiled against future emergencies.
You are talking about economics like a mathematical theorem when you know full well that economic behavior is an emergent social phenomenon and that people are not pure economic automata. This is disingenuous at best and dangerous at worst.
- mamon 7y agoYeah, right, government intervention and totalitarian control is the solution to all social problems... I very much prefer the free market solution of rising prices.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoIt should be obvious that a better solution is some mix of the two, and that mix will change from time to time and under different circumstances.
- mamon 7y agoYou know what would the "middle ground" solution be? Government buying masks at those spike prices to give them away for free to people who need them. This way you get all the benefits: everyone gets a mask when they need one and producers get incentive to increase supply. Now an interesting plot twist: Those masks not only do not protect against coronavirus (because the virus is too small, and can get through), they actually increase the risk of infection (because they serve as virus incubators, especially when they become wet)
- BoorishBears 7y agoI don’t. Even if the masks were actually being used properly, people who need masks the most after the sick, are the people we pay the lowest, retail workers, food service, people who come in contact with extreme numbers of people on a daily basis. Well paid tech employees can work from home, take 2 weeks of sick days and continue to make thousands a week. These people will come into work even if they’re anything short of dying because they’re more likely to live paycheck to paycheck when we don’t pay them enough, and the free market has decided not to give them sick benefits that we all benefit from. The free market is actually externalizing the issue to all of at this point. Don’t give workers enough sick days and keep all that profit, but then when the workers end up spreading the virus as a result of their boneheaded policies, the public will suffer, and the government will pay dearly.
- hef19898 7y agoFree market under true emergency situations won't work. As we see with masks right now and we are nowhere near a true global crisis. Why do you think governments went to rationing during war time?
- frank2 7y ago>Why do you think governments went to rationing during war time? I doubt it was to help individual citizens and families survive a crisis.
- hef19898 7y agoThat was exactly the reason. To not let the non-fighting part of the population die and keep the army in fighting shape.
- realusername 7y agoThat was exactly the reason, if you don't do rationing in extreme events, people start to mass panic buy everything and then you would have people starving. There's absolutely no "free market" anymore during panic.
- derefr 7y agoI believe you, but is there a good example of a time when this happened and a bunch of people died of starvation? (I assume there’d be plenty of them, since rationing isn’t a very obvious idea.)
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> That was exactly the reason, if you don't do rationing in extreme events, people start to mass panic buy everything Which is what pricing is for. If people start hoarding then the price goes up and makes hoarding much more expensive. Not only that, it gives the people with a stockpile a financial incentive to put it on eBay and thereby make it available for distribution to other people. Unless they're prohibited from doing so, in which case they carry on hoarding.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Another way is for the government to declare and emergency and order production Which generally doesn't have to be ordered, because producers are already inclined to produce more during high demand. You might also want to worry about the business consequences of ordering suppliers of critical products to spend money increasing capacity on an emergency basis without increasing their sales price. With no way to recover their now-higher costs, what happens when you drive them out of business and then need them again next time? > and to set rules about distribution like limiting people to one box at a time or whatever Which fails because some people have a legitimate need to buy in quantity, but it's an administrative nightmare to determine exactly who those people are and each failure to correctly identify results in a large quantity of items not going to people who legitimately need them. It also violates the social distancing principle. Instead of sending one person from an office to the store to buy a box for each person from the office to take home, now every employee has to individually visit the store and create a new opportunity to transmit or receive an infection with other patrons or staff there. > Markets are typically closer to economic optimality over the longer run but not in the short term, There is no principle that markets are more optimal in the long run than the short run. Market failures exist, but they exist where they exist and not where they don't. A huge demand spike isn't a market failure. The higher prices cause markets to do exactly what you want in that context -- increase production and reduce hoarding. > and furthermore optimality is not always that important for many commodities that can be stockpiled against future emergencies. This only works if they actually were stockpiled ahead of time, in which case there wouldn't be such a supply shortage that prices would rise to undesirable levels.
- anigbrowl 7y agoIt doesn't really seem worth engaging further with pseudo arguments like 'Market failures exist, but they exist where they exist and not where they don't.'