3 ms·
The author is Bo Winegard. RationalWiki at https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bo_Winegard https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bo_Winegard summarizes him thus: > Bo Wineg
by eesmith 7y ago
The author is Bo Winegard.
RationalWiki at https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bo_Winegard https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bo_Winegard summarizes him thus:
> Bo Winegard is an American hereditarian psychologist[2], nationalist[3] and pseudoscientist[4] associated with the online "race realist" community.[5] He writes discredited racialist pseudoscience articles for the right-wing online magazine Quillette[6][7][8] and surrounds himself with white nationalists, but complains if he is labelled one.
The section "Fired from Marietta College" says:
> In March 2020, Winegard was fired from his job as Assistant Professor of Psychology at Marietta College. He later wrote an article for Quillette stating that "many people disagree with my views about human population variation, about conservativism, about immigration, about economics, indeed about almost everything" but complained his sacking was an attack on academic freedom.[10]
- thu2111 7y agoAre you quoting RationalWiki to back up his complaint about it in his article? That paragraph matches his summary of what it claims about him, i.e. not exactly 'rational' writing. This is just one more story in a steady stream of such stories. It's pretty clear by now that academia is basically the opposite of what it claims to be. Not sure this new story really adds anything: the world outside of academia already got the message that "academic freedom" is a fiction, if it ever existed at all, and the supposed superiority of academic research is a lie - so much of it doesn't replicate or is just outright buggy. I used to be shocked by this sort of event but now I just wonder what these academics were thinking? Why would anyone stay in academia if they want to explore topics the hard-left ideologically rejects? It's obvious how that ends, now. Also: his mistake was apologising. He shouldn't have agreed that his tweets were badly worded or that he'd be more "strategic". If you're the victim of this sort of attack the right strategy is to attack back, strongly. You don't try and compromise with anonymous complainants, ever.
- throwaway68888 7y agoThe reason "academia" rejects him isn't because his claims are somehow disturbing or controversial - it's because they're scientifically bogus and there's enough reason to believe that he's not arguing in good faith. Scientists make plenty of controversial claims and aren't afraid to be vocal about it - see climate change, or the harmful effects of many products like tobacco, which used to be (and in many cases, still are) largely ignored by the general population.
- eesmith 7y agoI'm quoting RationalWiki because invariably - on topics which I understand - whatever I read on Quillette is whacky nonsense, while the summaries from RationalWiki are much better aligned to my independently drawn conclusions. Basically, I don't trust Quillette. Which you can see from earlier comments of mine - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=eesmith%20quillette&sort=byPopularity&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... . ("More Quillette nonsense." and "I don't understand why people keep linking to Quillette. Just about every article I've read from them seems like poor-quality scholarship.") I also don't trust editorials (even in large corporate media like the NYT) - and this is an editorial. And because my understanding of "evolutionary biology" is that the field is close to a joke, full of just-so stories which are not based on evolution, anthropology, or history. (See https://evolution-institute.org/why-evolutionary-psychology-probably-isnt-possible/ https://evolution-institute.org/why-evolutionary-psychology-... ) So there are several strikes against me placing trust in the honesty of this piece. Academia is hard-left? LOL! Who's been brainwashing you? At best it's American mid-left, which is far from hard-left. Do we see most professors marching in support for unions for college employees and grad students? Do we see professors on strike for increased salaries for grad students and adjuncts? Do we see massive numbers of professors advocating for free college education for all, and against the MBA takeover of universities? No. Even then, those position wouldn't be hard-left - that would be average European.
- woodandsteel 7y ago> Bo Winegard is an American hereditarian psychologist[2], nationalist[3] and pseudoscientist[4] associated with the online "race realist" community.[5] He writes discredited racialist pseudoscience articles for the right-wing online magazine Quillette[6][7][8] and surrounds himself with white nationalists, but complains if he is labelled one. What are some specific claims that Winegard makes that you consider false?
- eesmith 7y agoI think most of evolutionary psychology is made of just-so stories not based in evolution, anthropology, or history. See https://evolution-institute.org/why-evolutionary-psychology-probably-isnt-possible/ https://evolution-institute.org/why-evolutionary-psychology-... - "Why Evolutionary Psychology (Probably) Isn’t Possible" with the underlying paper at https://link.springer.com/epdf/10.1007/s13752-019-00336-4?shared_access_token=ZBkIZa1YiuE0LQx8Ahma9fe4RwlQNchNByi7wbcMAY6oc4laM4TmJijVKMoolnjpDhDOnhV8TTTUcQLqNu74B-gNKznqYTlhLGXnnYrIM4MaBSV38YtYwukwnpokq9XnfTUGyB6mvKA-zVrAg-MXHA%3D%3D https://link.springer.com/epdf/10.1007/s13752-019-00336-4?sh... "Is Evolutionary Psychology Possible?". Literally the first paper of Winegard's I read was http://dro.dur.ac.uk/28942/1/28942.pdf http://dro.dur.ac.uk/28942/1/28942.pdf which says in the abstract: > Humans evolved in the context of intense intergroup competition, and groups comprised of loyal members more often succeeded than those that were not. Therefore, selective pressures have consistently sculpted human minds to be "tribal," and group loyalty and concomitant cognitive biases likely exist in all groups. The "therefore" hides a deeply incorrect assumption, which is present throughout evolutionary psychology. To answer your question, I consider the inference to be false. Quoting the first of the two links I gave: > It’s not sufficient to assume that the required identities are obvious. They need to be demonstrated. Solving the matching problem requires knowing about the psychological architecture of our prehistoric ancestors. But it is difficult to see how this knowledge can possibly be acquired. We do not, and very probably cannot, know much about the prehistoric human mind. Some evolutionary psychologists dispute this. They argue that although we do not have access to these individuals’ minds, we can “read off” ancestral mechanisms from the adaptive challenges that they faced. For example, because predator-evasion was an adaptive challenge, natural selection must have installed a predator-evasion mechanism. This inferential strategy works only if all mental structures are adaptations, if adaptationist explanations are difficult to come by, and if adaptations are easily characterized. There is no reason to assume that all mental structures are adaptations, just as there is no reason to assume that all traits are adaptations. We also know that adaptationist hypotheses are easy to come by. And finally, there is the problem of how to characterize traits. Any adaptive problem characterized in a coarse-grained way (for example, “predator evasion”) can equally be characterized as an aggregate of finer-grained problems. And these can, in turn, be characterized as an aggregate for even finer-grained problems. This introduces indeterminacy and arbitrariness into how adaptive challenges are to be characterized, and therefore, what mental structures are hypothesized to be responses to those challenges. This difficulty raises an additional obstacle for resolving the matching problem. If there is no fact of the matter about how psychological mechanisms are to be individuated, then there is no fact of the matter about how they are to be matched. Indeed, standard evolutionary theory has a term - spandrel, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spandrel_(biology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spandrel_(biology) - for things which are a side-effect of adaptive selection for some other trait, rather than the main selective effect. The "therefore" in Winegard's paper does not acknowledge that "tribal" may be a spandrel, so is therefore a false assumption.