4 ms·
In a first world country like the US most people can save if they want to. It is not the 1%, more like the 80%. Think about it this way. Imagine your household
by GuB-42 7y ago
In a first world country like the US most people can save if they want to. It is not the 1%, more like the 80%.
Think about it this way. Imagine your household income is $50k, the median. But for one year, you decide to live like you are at $30k, barely above poverty. It may be a difficult year but there is no reason you can't manage, 1 in 5 people live their entire life with that. At the end of the year, you are left with $20k. You can now start living your life like anyone with a median income will. Because of that 1 frugal year, you are left with a average balance of $20k for your entire life. No more living paycheck to paycheck. And even better, when you die, your children will inherit these $20k so they won't need that year of poverty to keep their balance positive. So these $20k will actually last forever.
Of course, it is a simplification, but the idea is that keeping savings is just a matter of living with the paycheck of a few months ago instead of the last one.
Now what are the benefits of having an average of $20k that you won't touch.
First, it is insurance. Insurance costs you money in the long run, that's how insurance companies pay their employees. That sum is your own insurance for small things, like phones.
Second is that you can take advantage of opportunities, like volume discounts. Money will make you save money.
For those who are above the poverty line, the reason they can't save is lack of discipline. Not "the 1%". But to be fair, society in North America doesn't really help, with ads everywhere and credit everything.
- thefounder 7y agoYeah, live an even more miserable life so that you can save a little. You save your whole life what others make in a minute/hour/day
- claudeganon 7y agoMike Bloomberg spent 500 million dollars on advertisements for a failed presidential bid. With this money, he could've given every American a million dollars, still have 173 million left over, and have made no discernible impact on his net worth. It's absolutely an issue of the 1% versus everyone else, and especially given these people's opposition to providing basic social safety nets to all people. EDIT: I'm an idiot and didn't think through the math.
- Fricken 7y agoYou might want to double check your arithmetic.
- hyper_reality 7y ago$500m would give every American $1.50
- claudeganon 7y agoOh yeah I totally messed this one up.
- droidist2 7y agoYou're not the only one who messed that one up. https://twitter.com/KFILE/status/1235808311834021888 https://twitter.com/KFILE/status/1235808311834021888
- solotronics 7y agoReally? Hopefully this makes people think more critically about the drivel they hear on TV. This goes for both sides!
- GuB-42 7y agoNo, what I am saying is that by making your life "more miserable" for a short time, you can make the rest of your entire life better. It is called delayed gratification and it is linked to success in general. That is just an instance of it. And sure, I can save my whole life and make less than some people can make in an hour. Ok, good for them. But now what can we do? Take their money? It is not going to happen, so I think it is smarter to do with what we have instead of dreaming about a better world that will solve all our problems. And even if we manage to take all the money from "the 1%" and redistribute it to everyone else, it will be around $20k/year more per household. It is a lot, but not that much. Let's take our $50k/year median household, it is now $70k. In theory that means $20k/year of savings. But when you consider that many $70k/year households are living paycheck to paycheck (but with a nicer car and a slightly bigger house), it probably wont change the saving ability of the average American. Another way to show that the 1% has nothing to do with savings is to look at other countries. Even when adjusted to purchasing power and inequality, US households has less savings and more income than most western Europe countries.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYou end up with some of the following barriers to saving: 1. Cost of housing. We mostly don't have affordable housing. This is a serious burden for many Americans. It's not legal to live in a hut without electricity or the like, even if you wanted to. 2. Our public transportation and walkability sucks. Most Americans need a car. This is a huge financial and logistical burden for many people. 3. Healthcare The US spends insane amounts on healthcare and people who are poor let problems linger because they aren't sure if it's worth getting seen and having the bill for it. I've escaped that pattern. It was really challenging to escape it and I've been dirt poor a long time, in part because not having a car is a logistical barrier to earned income and even if isn't, it's a social signal that "I'm an incompetent loser" which helps suppress my income. I'm gradually making progress on all of it, but it is tough to swim against the tide and our current tide is highly problematic and burdensome for most people in the US. So it's a damned if you, damned if you don't situation.
- foogazi 7y agoI can see people at one point being burdened by some of the scenarios you mention but do they happen every year or every other year to everyone without 20k in the bank?
- chucky_z 7y agoYes, cars being the biggest problem. If you're broke and you buy a new car, you end up with a lease or something with a big down payment; the other option is you have a huge finance issue, where you won't finish paying off your car for 7 years after it has 100k+ miles, and now you still owe 5k on a car that's breaking down, with monthly payments of $500/month+. During this time, your rent has likely been raised each of these years. Also during this time, you started making 50k, and are probably still making 50k. The United States is in a very vicious cycle, mostly based around living, working, and commuting.
- triceratops 7y ago> If you're broke and you buy a new car That right there sounds like a self-created problem.