3 ms·
Showing that torture is an effective way for good guys to obtain something is particularly bad. However, I am not against the use of torture in films like Saw.
by GuB-42 7y ago
Showing that torture is an effective way for good guys to obtain something is particularly bad. However, I am not against the use of torture in films like Saw.
Saw is a horror movie. Horror movies are a way to experience scary things without putting you in actual danger. And they are not going to achieve that by just showing kittens playing, getting you to be scared/horrified/disgusted/... when you know you are perfectly safe and that the story is fiction is hard enough. So they use an arsenal of techniques, from jump scares to phobias and gruesome deaths. And torture is great for this. We can imagine what it feels like, we get to see the blood and gore, we know it something that happens in the real world,... Well made, torture scenes are very effective at creating tension when it is called for.
And I don't think we should not use them just because torture is atrocious in real life. When we go see a horror movie or thriller, we know the game, we don't want it to go easy on us. Deep inside, we know we are safe, that's what allows us to have fun playing with our limits.
Is it healthy? I think so, most kids love getting scared at some point, and they don't become psychopaths as a result. And horror stories, even the most tasteless ones definitely don't glorify what they are showing.
- ljm 7y agoFilms like Saw and The Human Centipede are probably just adrenaline rushes and quick thrills. I'm not keen on them because I tend to empathise too much with characters and, to be honest, I don't want to put myself in the shoes of someone facing their final moments with a reverse bear trap stuck to their face. It's generally why I'm not overly keen on violence in movies because I start to over-think or over-feel it, and those situations are so unrealistic that of course I can't comprehend it. I suppose that in itself is a form of cosmic horror but it's purely self inflicted, it's not what the movie is selling. Saw isn't a Lovecraft film. I wouldn't stop anyone else from watching them, and those movies aren't shit or trashy either (like some commenter has said). But I know my reasons for not enjoying them, and preferring horror that is more subtle, psychological, and rooted in realistic trauma that I've experienced myself. Torture is out of the picture because it's too often depicted as something the torturer can't wait to do, they're just held back by a system and they want to go rogue. You know, the trope of the torturer unfolding a cloth or a leather pouch to joyously reveal a bunch of surgical instruments. Or punching a guy in the face so hard it knocks their chair over; which in real life would probably put them in a coma.