3 ms·
pg should have taken the time to study some biology and he would have seen that virtually all exponential looking functions in complex ecosystems are s-curves,
by Barrin92 7y ago
pg should have taken the time to study some biology and he would have seen that virtually all exponential looking functions in complex ecosystems are s-curves, or else we would have likely been wiped off the planet by now.
PG and people in tech seem to be afflicted by what could be called "singularity brain disease", which routinely mistakes everything that goes up to the right on a graph too quickly for an exponential function. See also the club of rome paranoia about human overpopulation, the mentioned robot apocalypse, or whatever else is the fad of the year.
- btilly 7y agoPerhaps you should study some biology. What turns exponential functions into s-curves is a feedback loop. In the case of epidemics in the wild, the feedback loop is that people who have already had the disease tend not to get it again. Which means that, without external effort, a disease remains exponential until it has burned through a significant fraction of victims where it has already been. A disease that has affected thousands in regions with hundreds of millions should not yet be slowed by that kind of consideration.
- Barrin92 7y agothere are other exogenous factors like changes in temperature diminishing the spread of respiratory diseases over the summer, and avoidance of sick individuals happens quite naturally without having to stir up panic about exponential graphs on twitter. According to the WHO this virus, unlike influenza, does not seem to spread rapidly among asymptomatic people so the net effects of causing drama on twitter are probably going to create unnecessary anxiety in the population that will lead to mask hoarding or other unecessary behaviour.