I have some hearing loss as well, and this clearly would kill it for me, even if I thought it was a good idea otherwise. I actually walked through the programm

I have some hearing loss as well, and this clearly would kill it for me, even if I thought it was a good idea otherwise. I actually walked through the programming floor of what might be the largest pair-programming operation in the US and was shocked to see (and hear!) that it was concrete floors and ceilings with no sound treatment. Awful. My suspicion is that the jawboning about pair programming has more to do with the fact that it's a legal way to weed out older programmers than for any real economic benefits. We're more likely to have hearing loss, and will seem like poorer programmers in a pairing situation. Plus, we're overall less likely to put up with trendy bullshit like PP.