4 ms·
What is the difference between a Minsky moment and a top?
by hammock 7y ago
What is the difference between a Minsky moment and a top?
- tlholaday 7y ago> What is the difference between a Minsky moment and a top? Casually speaking, it’s the difference between a forced sale and profit taking.
- jnwatson 7y agoI think the bigger question is what is the difference between a Minsky moment and an inverse-short squeeze (a long squeeze?)?
- tlholaday 7y ago> I think the bigger question is what is the difference between a Minsky moment and an inverse-short squeeze (a long squeeze?)? Casually speaking, it’s the difference between a forced sale of an asset in order to repay debt after a long period of growth, and the incented but not mandatory sale of an asset which has increased substantially in price over a brief time, which is now abruptly declining, by owners hoping to salvage some of the gain.
- GrantZvolsky 7y agoThe term carries a negative connotation in that it implies guilt for the collapse.
- motohagiography 7y agoInstead of a short squeeze where asset prices rise and blow up people with naked/levered short positions on them, it's in effect, a long squeeze, where asset prices fall and then take a cascading fall as the result of leveraged (indebted) people trying to exit their positions. 2008 "underwater mortgages," where houses were worth less than the loans to pay for them cost was a Minsky moment. But above, the forced sale (bankruptcy avoidance) vs. profit taking a better view.
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoIt's the difference between describing causality and reporting facts. Not every top is caused by a Minsky moment. For instance, inventories could overshoot and then less stuff needs to be made for a while. Or central banks could raise interest rates to fight inflation. These are two of the most common causes of relatively benign recessions and market tops.