3 ms·
Setting aside the guidelines against clickbait titles or editorializing, one has to consider the tendency on HN for readers to only engage with the title, and n
by krapp 7y ago
Setting aside the guidelines against clickbait titles or editorializing, one has to consider the tendency on HN for readers to only engage with the title, and not read the article at all. Assuming for the sake of argument that most titles aren't egregiously misleading or clickbait to begin with, many might still be triggering and need to be toned down.
Also, HN limits all titles to 80 characters, because I guess everyone is reading this site on a terminal, so any title longer than that has to be edited.
What I don't like (besides the character limit) is when they change the URL and throw the context of the thread off. There ought to be some way to link the history of comments to the history of editorial changes but I can't think of a solution that HN would consider elegant.
- bookofjoe 7y agoI like the character limit because it forces me to really think hard about the piece in order to cram, say, a highly technical, oftimes abstruse 200-character scientific journal article title into the 80-character HN space.
- krapp 7y agoHN should be able to handle a highly technical article title, though. And if people can't, then someone can explain it in the comments. It becomes a problem when you lose necessary context in fitting the title in the limit, causing confusion or misinterpretation of the title. I've seen arguments started over it. There's one current example here[0] where "India’s Yes Bank" was shortened to Indian Bank" in the title to make up for the original being two characters over the limit. Turns out there's an actual "Indian Bank[1]" and now the title is misleading. All because we can't have a title with 82 characters. Granted, it doesn't happen often, but every time it does happen, it would have been trivially easy to avoid by either not having a character limit for titles, or having a more reasonable one like 120 characters. Edit: also apparently just happened here[2]. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22502649 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22502649 [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22504863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22504863 [2]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22504837 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22504837
- bookofjoe 7y agoTwitter wouldn't exist if it weren't for the character limit.
- krapp 7y agoTwitter's character limit was originally intended for posting on SMS, and remained long after it was even relevant. And they extended the limit recently anyway. And people work around it by linking multiple posts, so it doesn't even really matter. And... I'm specifically talking about title length, not article length. Tweets don't even have titles.