3 ms·
The big point here, which the author doesn't mention, is that you can have absence of evidence without searching for evidence or you can have absence of evidenc
by baddox 16y ago
The big point here, which the author doesn't mention, is that you can have absence of evidence without searching for evidence or you can have absence of evidence after rigorous searching.
I believe that the former situation is the one covered by the saying "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence." For example, I personally haven't observed any evidence of gravitational time dilation, because I haven't looked. I would be a fool to interpret this lack of evidence as evidence that gravitational time dilation doesn't exist. The engineers of the Global Positioning System have evidence.
However, after a reasonably rigorous search, one may indeed reasonably conclude that something doesn't exist if no evidence of it has been found, especially when evidence would be easily visible if the thing did exist. The examples the author gave fall into this category: Most likely, given the distribution of humans on Earth, there would be evidence of dodo birds if they were extant.
Now, it's important to be careful when estimating the likelihood of stumbling upon evidence of something. Hundreds of new species (most only subtly different than known species) are discovered every year, and there are undoubtedly thousands of oceanic creatures that have never been seen by humans, much less captured and dissected. It would be foolish to deny that there aren't hundreds or thousands of yet-undiscovered species simply because as of now we have no evidence of them.